Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

​​

12/10/2026

IT: The Tribunal of Rome ruled that if the applicant expressed the wish to seek international protection before 12 June 2026, the application must be deemed submitted on the date of such expression and remained subject to the legislation in force at that time, even if it had not been formally lodged due to the unlawful conduct of the national administration.

12/10/2026

IT: The Tribunal of Rome ruled that if the applicant expressed the wish to seek international protection before 12 June 2026, the application must be deemed submitted on the date of such expression and remained subject to the legislation in force at that time, even if it had not been formally lodged due to the unlawful conduct of the national administration.

ECLI
Input Provided By
EUAA Information and Analysis Sector (IAS)
Other Source/Information
Type
Judgment
Original Documents
Relevant Legislative Provisions
Recast Asylum Procedures Directive (Directive 2013/32/EU on common procedures for granting and withdrawing international protection) (recast APD) and/or APD 2005/85/CE; Regulation (EU) 2024/1348 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 May 2024 establishing a common procedure for international protection in the Union and repealing Directive 2013/32/EU (APR)
Reference
Italy, Civil Court [Tribunale], Applicant v Ministry of the Interior (Ministero dell'Interno),Questura of Rome, R.G. 25435/2026, 12 October 2026. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.
Permanent link to the case
https://caselaw.euaa.europa.eu/pages/viewcaselaw.aspx?CaseLawID=6333
Case history
Other information

European Union, Court of Justice of the European Union [CJEU], Evelyn Danqua v Minister for Justice and Equality,and Attorney General [Danqua], C-429/15 , ECLI:EU:C:2016:789, 20 October 2016.

Abstract

By application pursuant to Articles 281-decies et seq. of the Code of Civil Procedure, filed on 10 May 2026 and accompanied by a request for interim relief, a Peruvian national sought a declaration of her right to access the asylum procedure through the receipt and lodging of her application for international protection before the Questura of Rome, together with an order requiring the latter to receive and lodge her application, including by way of interim relief. The applicant stated that she had arrived in Italy in February 2026 and she repeatedly and unsuccessfully attempted to request international protection at the Questura of Rome in April and subsequently decided to express her wish to seek international protection by sending a certified email to the Questura on 15 April 2026. The applicant highlighted the serious and irreparable harm suffered, referring to her circumstances as a single woman without access to support or accommodation while waiting for the authorities to receive her application, thereby placing her in a vulnerable situation, given the serious infringement of her fundamental rights, including, in particular, the right to work, to register with the municipal registry, to access the healthcare system and accommodation and reception services, in the absence of receipt and lodging of her application. The applicant submitted written observations arguing that the EU Pact on Migration and Asylum, which entered into application during the proceedings, was not applicable to the case.


The Tribunal of Rome noted that the applicant had unsuccessfully attempted to submit her application for international protection in person and had therefore had no alternative but to submit a request by certified email through her legal representative. It considered that, through this email, she had expressed a clear and unequivocal wish to seek international protection. It referred to case law from the Court of Cassation, according to which the expression of the wish to seek asylum may take place through any suitable act, including a certified email addressed to the administration. The tribunal also pointed to the practice of the Questura of Rome of neither scheduling appointments online nor providing any booking mechanism, instead requiring asylum applicants to appear physically at the counters, resulting in long queues, without any possibility of predicting the actual time of access. In this regard, the tribunal referenced several newspaper reports documenting such practice. Hence, the tribunal held that the applicant had adequately expressed to the Questura her wish to seek international protection by means of the certified email sent on 15 April 2026, and that the Questura should have proceeded to formalise it within the statutory time limits and initiate the examination procedure by forwarding the documents to the Territorial Commission for examination.


The tribunal recalled that the asylum procedure is governed by prompt and certain time limits, aimed at ensuring the effective enjoyment of the rights associated with the status of asylum applicant, as provided for by Article 3 of Legislative Decree No. 25/2008. This Legislative Decree, in its previous wording implementing the recast Asylum Procedures Directive, required the Questura, under Article 26, to draw up a record of the applicant's statements within 3 working days from the expression of the wish to seek protection. In its current wording, the second paragraph provides, with regard to the time limits for the registration and lodging of the application, for an express reference to Article 26 of the APR. The tribunal cited the CJEU judgment in Evelyn Danqua v Minister for Justice and Equality,and Attorney General [Danqua] (C-429/15, 20 October 2016) which held, under the previous legislation and in the absence of rules laid down by EU law concerning the procedural arrangements for the submission and examination of an application for international protection, that it was for the domestic legal system of each Member State to regulate such arrangements, while ensuring that they did not make the exercise of rights conferred by EU law practically impossible or excessively difficult. The tribunal concluded that the expression of the wish to seek protection, which is not subject to any formal requirements, is sufficient to give rise to an obligation on the part of the administration to receive it and record it within the strict time limits laid down by national and international legislation. The tribunal therefore held that the Questura of Rome had engaged in an unlawful practice, failing to allow the formalisation of the application within the prescribed time limits and failing to schedule an appointment for that purpose. It noted that a situation had arisen which effectively prevented the exercise of an inalienable human right, namely the constitutionally and internationally protected right to seek protection. Considering that the impossibility of submitting an application at the competent offices, following the expression of such wish by certified email, resulted from the unlawful conduct of the administration, the tribunal found that the applicant could not be made to bear the consequences thereof with regard to the applicable legal framework.


The tribunal finally clarified that the date of submission of the application must be deemed to be 15 April 2026, when the applicant clearly and unequivocally expressed her wish to the competent administration. It considered the administration's failure to formalise the application irrelevant and held that the legislation in force at the time of submission was therefore applicable, namely the legal framework preceding the amendments introduced by the Pact. The tribunal noted that Article 79(3) APR, which provides that the APR applies to applications lodged as of 12 June 2026, links the temporal dividing line to the lodging of the application, an activity falling within the Administration's control rather than that of the applicant. Referring to the definition of an application under Article 3(1)(12) of the APR and the provision governing when an application is deemed to have been made under Article 26(1) of the APR, the tribunal held that the expression of the wish to seek international protection has independent legal significance in relation to the subsequent stages of registration (Article 27) and lodging (Article 28). The tribunal further held that the date of lodging cannot be the sole determining factor, as this would allow the administration, in cases where the wish was expressed before 12 June 2026, to unilaterally affect the determination of the applicable legal framework by merely postponing the lodging of the application. This would undermine the principles of legal certainty, protection of legitimate expectations, equal treatment and effective judicial protection. In the present case, the tribunal noted that the application had not been lodged as a result of the unlawful conduct of the administration, whereas the wish referred to in Article 3(1)(12) of the APR had already been expressed before the entry into force of the APR. Therefore, the transitional provisions based on the date of lodging could not apply, and the application consequently remained subject to the previous legal framework. According to the tribunal, this interpretation was consistent with the provisions laid down in Article 17 of Decree-Law No. 100 of 12 June 2026 (converted by Law No. 145/2026), containing transitional provisions for the implementation of the Pact. The fourth paragraph of that Article specifically refers to the legislation applicable to administrative proceedings initiated before the entry into force of the APR, providing that the previous legislation shall continue to apply to such proceedings. The tribunal observed that, in this Article, the use of the term “submission” excluded the possibility of considering it synonymous with “lodging”. In this way, the national legislature clarified a matter not provided for by EU legislation, namely which legislation applies to proceedings initiated by an expression of the wish to seek international protection, expressed and received by an authorised authority, and therefore by an application to be deemed “submitted” before 12 June 2026.


Therefore, the tribunal concluded that the claim should be upheld on the merits. It ordered the Questura of Rome to summon the applicant for the purpose of registering and lodging her application in accordance with the legislation in force in April 2026, thereby enabling her to regularise her presence in Italian territory and, consequently, to enjoy all fundamental rights associated with a regular legal status, starting with access to healthcare and employment.


Note: The Tribunal of Rome issued a substantially identical decision in judgment R.G. 24772/2026 of 29 September 2026. 


Note: to access the original judgment users must create an account (free) on Meltingpot.org.


 


Country of Decision
Italy
Court Name
IT: Civil Court [Tribunale]
Case Number
R.G. 25435/2026
Date of Decision
12/10/2026
Country of Origin
Peru
Keywords
Access to asylum procedures
Rights/Obligations of applicants