Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

​​

08/10/2026

CZ: The Constitutional Court ruled that the decisions of the Ministry of the Interior, Municipal court in Prague and Supreme Administrative Court violated the applicant’s rights to human dignity and fair procedure, as well as the principle of non-refoulement. The applicant, a woman from Uganda who claimed to have been abducted, tortured and raped because of her women’s rights advocacy, had her subsequent application rejected without taking into account her trauma-related vulnerability, and without proper assessment of the new information, COI, and internal protection alternative.

08/10/2026

CZ: The Constitutional Court ruled that the decisions of the Ministry of the Interior, Municipal court in Prague and Supreme Administrative Court violated the applicant’s rights to human dignity and fair procedure, as well as the principle of non-refoulement. The applicant, a woman from Uganda who claimed to have been abducted, tortured and raped because of her women’s rights advocacy, had her subsequent application rejected without taking into account her trauma-related vulnerability, and without proper assessment of the new information, COI, and internal protection alternative.

ECLI
ECLI:CZ:US:2026:3.US.3045.25.2
Input Provided By
EUAA Information and Analysis Sector (IAS)
Other Source/Information
Type
Judgment
Original Documents
Relevant Legislative Provisions
Recast Asylum Procedures Directive (Directive 2013/32/EU on common procedures for granting and withdrawing international protection) (recast APD) and/or APD 2005/85/CE; Recast Qualification Directive (Directive 2011/95/EU on standards for the qualification of third-country nationals or stateless persons as BIP for a uniform status for refugees or for persons eligible for subsidiary protection)(recast QD)/or QD 2004/83/EC
Reference
Czech Republic, Constitutional Court [Ústavní Soud], A. A. v Supreme Administrative Court,Municipal Court in Prague,Ministry of the Interior (Ministerstvo vnitra České republiky), III.ÚS 3045/25, ECLI:CZ:US:2026:3.US.3045.25.2, 08 October 2026. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.
Permanent link to the case
https://caselaw.euaa.europa.eu/pages/viewcaselaw.aspx?CaseLawID=6310
Case history
Other information
Abstract

A. A., national of Uganda, applied for international protection in Czechia for the first time in 2018. She claimed that she had been abducted, tortured and raped in Uganda as she belonged to a voluntary women's club which raised concerns about rapes and killings of women and authorities' failure to investigate them, and after she participated in a demonstration against a murder of one of the club's members. The applicant claimed that the police had refused to accept her complaint, she had moved to a different location with her children, and had continued to receive frightening phone calls. She then fled Uganda.


By decision of 8 April 2019, the Ministry of the Interior (the Ministry) refused to grant the applicant international protection. On 12 June 2020, the Regional Court in Hradec Králové annulled the Ministry's decision and remitted the case for re-examination. On 31 August 2021, the Ministry again refused to grant the applicant international protection. On 17 January 2022, the Regional Court in Ostrava upheld the Ministry's refusal, and on 28 February 2023, the Supreme Administrative Court dismissed the applicant's cassation complaint as inadmissible.


In September 2023, the applicant lodged a subsequent application for international protection, presenting new information received from her adoptive mother. The applicant claimed that unknown men had recently been asking about her and another member of the women's club had been abducted and murdered. Her adoptive mother warned the applicant against returning to Uganda. By decision of 16 September 2024, the Ministry rejected the subsequent application as inadmissible. On 29 May 2025, the Municipal Court in Prague upheld the Ministry's inadmissibility decision, and on 4 September 2025, the Supreme Administrative Court dismissed the applicant's cassation complaint as inadmissible.


The applicant filed a constitutional complaint with the Constitutional Court against the Ministry's inadmissibility decision on her subsequent application, the judgment of the Municipal Court in Prague, and the Supreme Administrative Court decision. On 22 October 2025, the Constitutional Court suspended the execution of those challenged decisions, pending its own determination.


By judgment of 8 October 2026, the Constitutional Court annulled the challenged decisions, ruling that they had violated the applicant's right to human dignity under Article 10(1) of the Czech Charter of Fundamental Rights and Freedoms (which forms part of the Czech constitutional order) (the Charter), right to fair procedure under Article 36(1) of the Charter, and the principle of non-refoulement under Article 33(1) of the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees (1951 Convention).


First, regarding the applicant's vulnerability, the Constitutional Court ruled that the Ministry and the administrative courts failed to take her vulnerability into account throughout the asylum procedure, violating her constitutional rights to human dignity and fair procedure. The Constitutional Court held that the Ministry and the administrative courts were obliged to assess the applicant's vulnerability. Such obligation represents a mechanism to protect the principles of equality and non-discrimination, the right to human dignity, prohibition of torture and cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment, protection of private life and the right to fair procedure.


The Constitutional Court reminded that vulnerability directly impacts the applicant's account and ability to respond to questions during the asylum interview and, referring to Article 4 of the recast Qualification Directive (recast QD) and the EUAA's (formerly EASO) Practical Guide: Evidence assessment (2015), it recalled that trauma is one of the individual factors that needs to be taken into account in a credibility assessment, which has to be carried out without prejudice and stereotypes. The Constitutional Court further held that, based on its own and Supreme Administrative Court's jurisprudence, survivors of rape and other sexual violence must be treated in a sensitive and supportive manner, and hesitation to share certain details due to their trauma cannot be held against them.


In the present case, the applicant explained that remembering her abduction and repeated rape was re-traumatising for her, which is why her adoptive mother also shared only limited new information with her regarding the unknown men's visits and the murder of the other women's club member. The applicant also explained that she did not wish to further inquire and think about it, as it brings back negative memories. While the Ministry and the Supreme Administrative Court did not take this circumstance into account in any way, the Municipal Court in Prague held it against the applicant, stating that her lack of interest means that she faced no threat related to the women's club, and hence there are no new reasons that would increase the risk of her persecution or serious harm.


The Constitutional Court held that such assessment violates the principles of assessing and taking into account the applicant's vulnerability. Contrary to the Municipal Court's opinion, vulnerability is not established only by a medical diagnosis, and trauma can be manifested through anxiety, fear, helplessness, shame, memory loss, and avoidance of details. In spite of the applicant pointing out to such trauma, the Ministry and the administrative courts either wrongly assessed or ignored it, contrary to their obligation to conduct the interview and assess any gaps and discrepancies in the applicant's account in light of her trauma.


Second, regarding the justification of the inadmissibility of the subsequent application, the Constitutional Court ruled that the errors committed by the Ministry and the administrative courts violated the applicant's right to fair procedure, as well as the principle of non-refoulement. Referring to the recast Asylum Procedure Directive (recast APD) and the EUAA's Practical Guide on Subsequent Applications (2021), the Constitutional Court recalled that for certain reasons, the applicant cannot, through no fault of their own, provide certain information in the previous procedure. Such reasons include difficulty in obtaining evidence, psychological state, trauma, vulnerability, and sexual and gender-based reasons.


The Constitutional Court found incorrect the Supreme Administrative Court's conclusion that the Ministry had gathered sufficient evidence about the current situation in Uganda when it decided on the inadmissibility of the subsequent application. To the contrary, it held that the Ministry and the administrative courts failed to assess the country of origin information (COI) on ineffective protection of women in Uganda, submitted by the applicant, and relied merely on the assessment in the first decision.


The Constitutional Court also rejected the finding that the new information related to the applicant (i.e. that unknown men had been asking about her and another member of the women's club had been abducted and murdered) was not credible, as the Ministry and the administrative courts did not try to clarify whether the murder could be connected to the applicant.


The Constitutional Court found incorrect the Municipal Court's conclusion that the applicant is not at risk because Uganda has enacted relevant laws, although they are not sufficiently enforced, and some murders and rapes are investigated. Referring to Article 7(2) of the recast QD and UNHCR's Guidelines on International Protection: Gender-Related Persecution within the context of Article 1A(2) of the 1951 Convention and/or its 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees (2002), the Constitutional Court held that the state's systematic failure to protect women from serious forms of gender-based violence (GBV) is in itself a form of persecution, and formal prohibition of violence against women is irrelevant without real protection. The Constitutional Court also considered irrelevant the Municipal Court's comparison of the situation in Uganda with Afghanistan, and its reference to a project that helps GBV survivors in Uganda overcome systemic barriers in accessing justice. The latter, in fact, only confirmed that GBV is a major problem in Uganda and state protection is ineffective.


Finally, the Constitutional Court rejected the finding that the applicant could internally relocate and access protection in Uganda, as the Ministry and the administrative courts failed to assess whether effective internal protection is available in a specific area of Uganda, taking into account the applicant's vulnerability. The Ministry and the administrative courts also omitted the fact that the applicant already unsuccessfully attempted to use internal protection when she reported her abduction and repeated rape, but the police refused to accept her complaint.


In conclusion, the Constitutional Court annulled the decisions of the Ministry, Municipal Court in Prague, and Supreme Administrative Court, finding violations of the applicant's right to human dignity, right to fair procedure and the principle of non-refoulement. The Constitutional Court ordered a new examination, taking into account the applicant's vulnerability.


Country of Decision
Czech Republic
Court Name
CZ: Constitutional Court [Ústavní Soud]
Case Number
III.ÚS 3045/25
Date of Decision
08/10/2026
Country of Origin
Uganda
Keywords
Assessment of applications
Country of Origin Information (COI)
Credibility
EUAA Materials
EUAA Other Materials
Gender based persecution
Internal protection alternative/ flight alternative
Non-refoulement
Special procedures
Subsequent application
Torture or inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment
Vulnerable group
Mental/psychological health