Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

​​

26/11/2020

PT: The Central Administrative Court upheld the exclusion of an Iraqi national from international protection on the basis that he represented a danger or founded threat to internal or external security or public order. Although the available intelligence did not establish the alleged terrorist involvement with certainty, the court considered the assessment of the Portuguese Security Intelligence Service together with other evidence including a judicial detention order on national-security grounds, sufficient to meet the applicable threshold for exclusion.

26/11/2020

PT: The Central Administrative Court upheld the exclusion of an Iraqi national from international protection on the basis that he represented a danger or founded threat to internal or external security or public order. Although the available intelligence did not establish the alleged terrorist involvement with certainty, the court considered the assessment of the Portuguese Security Intelligence Service together with other evidence including a judicial detention order on national-security grounds, sufficient to meet the applicable threshold for exclusion.

ECLI
Input Provided By
EUAA Courts and Tribunals Network
Other Source/Information
Type
Judgment
Original Documents
Relevant Legislative Provisions
Recast Qualification Directive (Directive 2011/95/EU on standards for the qualification of third-country nationals or stateless persons as BIP for a uniform status for refugees or for persons eligible for subsidiary protection)(recast QD)/or QD 2004/83/EC
Reference
Portugal, Central Administrative Court [Tribunal Central Administrativo], A v Ministry of the Interior (Ministerio del Interior), No. 1448/19.2BELSB, 26 November 2020. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.
Permanent link to the case
https://caselaw.euaa.europa.eu/pages/viewcaselaw.aspx?CaseLawID=6197
Case history
Other information
Abstract

According to the summary provided by the EUAA Courts and Tribunals Network:


The case concerned an Iraqi national who was transferred to Portugal from Greece under the EU relocation programme and subsequently applied for international protection. Although the applicant's claim disclosed elements potentially relevant to subsidiary protection, the Portuguese authorities ultimately refused both refugee status and subsidiary protection on the basis of the exclusion clauses contained in Article 9(1)(d) and Article 9(2)(b) of the Portuguese Asylum Act (Law No. 27/2008).


The exclusion assessment was based primarily on information provided by the Portuguese Security Intelligence Service (SIS) and information received through international cooperation. According to the information available to the authorities, the applicant had allegedly been identified as having links to the Islamic State (ISIL/Daesh), including alleged membership of the organisation, possible involvement in activities linked to terrorism, and possible links to a planned terrorist attack in Germany. The SIS further assessed that, if the available information were confirmed, the applicant could constitute a risk to European and Portuguese internal security. Criminal investigations concerning possible terrorist-related activities had also been opened.


A particular feature of the case is that the information relied upon by the authorities was largely classified. During the asylum proceedings, the applicant challenged both the sufficiency of the evidence and the lack of access to the underlying intelligence material. The court nevertheless accepted that information classified for national security reasons could be relied upon in exclusion proceedings, even where full disclosure to the applicant was not possible. The Court considered that the restrictions on access to the information resulted from the applicable national framework governing classified intelligence and did not in themselves render the exclusion decision unlawful.


The TCAS acknowledged that the available information did not establish the applicant's involvement in terrorist activities with certainty and referred repeatedly to the existence of suspicions, probabilities and risk assessments rather than proven facts. Nevertheless, the Court attached significant weight to the assessment carried out by the SIS, whose statutory mission includes the prevention of terrorism and the protection of national security. The court also relied on the existence of a judicial decision ordering the applicant's placement in a temporary detention facility on national security grounds pursuant to Article 35-A of the Portuguese Asylum Act.


Taken together, these elements were considered sufficient to conclude that the applicant represented a "danger or founded threat to internal or external security or to public order" within the meaning of Article 9 of the Portuguese Asylum Act. The court therefore upheld the refusal of both refugee status and subsidiary protection.


Country of Decision
Portugal
Court Name
PT: Central Administrative Court [Tribunal Central Administrativo]
Case Number
No. 1448/19.2BELSB
Date of Decision
26/11/2020
Country of Origin
Iraq
Keywords
Classified information
Danger to the national security or the community
Exclusion
Terrorism