The application for international protection of a Turkish national in the Netherlands was rejected by the State Secretary for Justice and Security on 17 April 2019, on the grounds that he was excluded from international protection for having committed crimes falling within the scope of Article 1(F) of the Refugee Convention. He was sentenced in Türkiye to life imprisonment for committing murders and assaults on 11 November 2010.
The applicant submitted a subsequent asylum application, arguing that his conviction in Türkiye was based on confessions obtained through torture, including sexual violence, and therefore Article 1(F) of the Refugee Convention should not apply. To support his position that he was unable to disclose the torture during that first asylum procedure because he felt ashamed, he submitted a report from the Netherlands institute for Human Rights and Medical Assesment (iMMO) dated 6 December 2018. The report stated that the applicant suffered from psychological problems during the asylum procedure, which very likely interfered with his ability to provide a complete, coherent, and consistent statement. The report further stated that there were significant shame and associated avoidance as a defence mechanism, which is consistent with the alleged sexual violence. The State Secretary also rejected the subsequent application.
The applicant challenged the negative decisions. The District Court of The Hague, seated in Haarlem, upheld the first appeal on 28 January 2020, finding that the State Secretary did not sufficiently substantiate that the iMMO report did not meet the requirements and therefore could not disregard the conclusions contained in the iMMO report. The court concluded that a further medical examination is needed to assess the credibility of the alleged torture. The State Secretary appealed the judgment before the Council of State.
The Council of State found that the iMMO did not establish in a sufficiently clear and reasoned manner that shame concerning the alleged torture was the cause of the limited ability to provide a complete, coherent and consistent statement. Nevertheless, the possibility that shame hindered the applicant in making statements must be considered by the State Secretary when assessing credibility. The Council of State concluded that if the State Secretary does not engage a medical expert and does not dispute the conclusions of the iMMO report, but nevertheless considers the applicant not credible, it must provide further reasoning on why he reaches that conclusion. Thus, the Council of State referred the case back to the District Court.
On 22 December 2021, the District Court upheld the appeal of the applicant again, finding that the State Secretary took insufficiently into account and explained that shame may have prevented the applicant from making statements about the alleged torture. The District Court found also that the State Secretary insufficiently considered that the medical evidence supported the applicant's allegations of torture.
The State Secretary filed an appeal against this judgment before the Council of State, arguing that it was the applicant's responsibility to demonstrate that he was unable to speak about the torture during the first asylum procedure because of shame. The State Secretary argued that the applicant also failed to establish this with the iMMO report and did not mention the torture or shame in the first asylum application procedure. Lastly, the State Secretary argued that the applicant failed to submit the criminal judgment from Türkiye.
The Council of State considered whether it is plausible that shame prevented the applicant from making statements about the torture. The Council of State upheld the district court's decision, stating that the State Secretary did not demonstrably considered the conclusions of the iMMO report in his decision. The Council of State found that the State Secretary should not have attached such significant negative weight to the fact that the applicant had not made the statements about torture earlier. The court held that the State Secretary failed to adequately substantiate that shame had not prevented the applicant from giving statements.
The Council of State referred to the iMMO report, stating that it can take a long time before people, and particularly men, speak about sexual violence. The court held that the case-file documents contained sufficient indications that shame already played a role for a considerable period of time and that this progressively worsened. The Council of State concluded that the State Secretary failed to provide adequate reasons for considering the applicant's statements not credible, despite the iMMO's findings.
Furthermore, the court held that the State Secretary failed to sufficiently consider the reports from the Netherlands Institute for Forensic Psychiatry and Psychology and the Netherlands Forensic Institute in the assessment and that these reports together with the iMMO report support the applicant's allegations of torture. The court stated that these reports support the conclusions in the iMMO report, finding that there is presumably a connection between the anxiety symptoms, feelings of shame and avoidance, and psychological traumatisation. Thus, the court found that the State Secretary could not simply rely on the statements made during the initial asylum interview and on the position that the applicant's statements concerning the torture and sexual violence were therefore not credible.
On the criminal proceeding, the Council of State held that if it is accepted as credible that the applicant was tortured during the criminal proceedings in Türkiye and became a victim of sexual violence and therefore made a confessional statement, the criminal proceedings as a whole are, in principle, unreliable. The court referred to the judgment of the ECtHR of 17 January 2012, Othman (Abu Qatada) v. the United Kingdom, according to which a judgment that is based, in part, on a confession obtained under torture is incompatible with the right to a fair trial under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights. The court held that if a conviction is based, at least in part, on confessional statements obtained under torture, the State Secretary may not rely on that conviction as the basis for applying Article 1(F) of the Refugee Convention.
The appeal was declared unfounded, and the judgment of the district court, annulling the decision of the State Secretary, was upheld. The Council of State held that the State Secretary must take a new decision while reconsidering the entire asylum application in light of the conclusions of the iMMO and pointed out the aspects the State Secretary must consider in the assessment, such as the medical reports and the possibility that the applicant was previously unable to give statements about torture because of shame.