Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

​​

06/07/2022
HR: The High Administrative Court upheld the exclusion of an Iranian applicant, holding that, on the basis of the Security and Intelligence Agency's opinion, the applicant posed a threat to national security and public order, and that his activities related to the smuggling of persons constituted acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations under Article 1(3) of the UN Charter.
06/07/2022
HR: The High Administrative Court upheld the exclusion of an Iranian applicant, holding that, on the basis of the Security and Intelligence Agency's opinion, the applicant posed a threat to national security and public order, and that his activities related to the smuggling of persons constituted acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations under Article 1(3) of the UN Charter.

ECLI
ECLI:HR:VUS:2020:101
Input Provided By
EUAA Information and Analysis Sector (IAS)
Other Source/Information
Type
Judgment
Original Documents
Relevant Legislative Provisions
European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR); Recast Qualification Directive (Directive 2011/95/EU on standards for the qualification of third-country nationals or stateless persons as BIP for a uniform status for refugees or for persons eligible for subsidiary protection)(recast QD)/or QD 2004/83/EC; UN International Covenants / UN Conventions
Reference
Croatia, High Administrative Court [Visoki upravni sud], A.M.H.A. v Ministry of the Interior of the Republic of Croatia‚ Directorate for Immigration‚ Citizenship and Administrative Affairs (Ministarstva unutarnjih poslova Republike Hrvatske‚ Uprave za imigraciju‚ državljanstvo i upravne poslove), Usž-4354/19-3, ECLI:HR:VUS:2020:101, 06 July 2022. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.
Permanent link to the case
https://caselaw.euaa.europa.eu/pages/viewcaselaw.aspx?CaseLawID=6006
Case history
Other information

European Union, Court of Justice of the European Union [CJEU], Germany v B and D, C-57/09 and C-101/09, EU:C:2010:661, 09 November 2010. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.

Abstract

On 9 July 2019, the Administrative Court in Zagreb dismissed the action of an Iranian national seeking annulment of the Ministry of the Interior's decision of 14 June 2018, by which the ministry annulled the international protection previously granted to the applicant on 23 September 2014 and rejected his application for international protection on grounds of exclusion. The ministry based its decision on the opinion of the Security and Intelligence Agency, which determined that the applicant posed a threat to national security and public order, the exclusion being tied to acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations. The applicant lodged an appeal against the first-instance judgment before the High Administrative Court.


In his appeal, he argued that exclusion clauses must be interpreted restrictively given the serious consequences for a person who fears persecution, citing the UNHCR Handbook on procedures and criteria for determining refugee status. He argued that the application of the clause requires a balance to be struck between the nature of the offence allegedly committed and the degree of feared persecution, and that the clause, being general in character and to be read in light of the humanitarian object of the Convention, cannot be applied broadly. He maintained that the act of smuggling of persons cannot be subsumed under acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations within the meaning of Article 1F(c). He relied on the CJEU judgment in Germany v B and D (C-57/09 and C-101/09, 9 November 2010), to claim that membership of, or active support for, an organisation does not automatically amount to a serious basis for treating a person's acts as a serious non-political crime or as acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the UN, and that exclusion must instead rest on an individual assessment of the facts of each case. He argued that no such individual assessment had been carried out in his case, that no proportionality had been established between the nature of the offence and the degree of danger he faced, and that his application had been rejected without first stating the reasons for which he would qualify for asylum. He alleged erroneous and incomplete establishment of the facts and incorrect application of procedural and substantive law, and asserted that the contested decision was contrary to Croatia's obligations under the ECHR and its Protocols. He sought annulment of both the first-instance judgment and the decision of the ministry.


The ministry maintained the reasoning of its decision, stating that the offence had been correctly characterised as smuggling of persons, that the applicant's conviction for that offence was sufficient to conclude that he posed a danger to national security or public order, and that this was confirmed by the opinion of the Security and Intelligence Agency.


The High Administrative Court found the appeal unfounded. The court considered that the first-instance judgment had set out all the essential facts and given sufficient and valid reasons for rejecting the action, which it fully accepted. On the substance, the court held that, on the basis of the official documentation of the body competent for security clearances under the Security Clearance Act and the opinion of the Security and Intelligence Agency, the existence of a security obstacle had been established and the applicant had been determined to pose a threat to national security and public order, so that the conditions for annulment of international protection had occurred. Contrary to the applicant's arguments, the court held that the first-instance court had correctly assessed, on the basis of the file and the applicant's own statements, that activities related to the smuggling of persons constitute acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations under the UN Charter, reasoning that in a broader sense the smuggling of persons is an international problem of an economic, social and humanitarian nature whose resolution falls within the objectives of the United Nations under Article 1(3) of the Charter. The court considered that the appeal objections were unfounded and that the first-instance court had remedied shortcomings in the reasoning of the contested decision by stating the reasons and the exact provision serving as the basis for exclusion. It noted that the ministry had established that the facts on which asylum had originally been granted continued to exist, and that the failure to restate those reasons in the contested decision had no bearing on the fulfilment of the conditions for excluding the applicant.


Country of Decision
Croatia
Court Name
HR: High Administrative Court [Visoki upravni sud]
Case Number
Usž-4354/19-3
Date of Decision
06/07/2022
Country of Origin
Iran
Keywords
Appeal / Second instance determination
Classified information
Danger to the national security or the community
Exclusion
Acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the UN
Withdrawal/End/Revocation/Renewal of protection