A Turkish national had been living in Czechia for more than 14 years and had applied for international protection twice. In his first application of January 2008, he stated that he was a member of the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) and was in danger in Türkiye. He claimed that he returned from Germany in 2006 after an unsuccessful asylum application, joined the PKK and fought in the mountains against the Turkish army, before the PKK helped him leave Türkiye. International protection was refused by decision of 22 January 2008.
On 11 January 2022, while serving a prison sentence, the applicant submitted a subsequent application. He stated that he had worked as a PKK fighter for several years and was at risk of persecution by the ruling party, as were all PKK sympathisers and members. He referred to a report published on 26 September 2021 which named him in full, stated that he had been a PKK fighter, and displayed leaked photographs showing his face and depicting him posing with a weapon in clothing typical of PKK members. He further stated that he was a member of the pro-Kurdish Peoples' Democratic Party (HDP) party and of the organisation DemKurd in Vienna, and considered himself an active supporter of the human rights of Kurds. During the interview the applicant explained, in response to identified contradictions, that his participation in PKK fighting had lasted about six months rather than years. He confirmed that he had repeatedly returned to Türkiye after that time (including in 2011 and 2016), that he had been detained and interrogated at the airport in connection with the PKK and released, and that he had children in the Czech Republic whom he wished to see.
The applicant had been convicted by the Czech criminal courts on three occasions, including 42 months imprisonment for abuse of a person living in a common dwelling and extortion committed against his wife, 52 months for attempted grievous bodily harm and misdemeanour hooliganism arising from an assault on two persons in a bistro, and 30 months imprisonment and indefinite expulsion for extortion. The sentences totalled almost seven years and the third offence was committed during the applicant's probationary period.
By decision of 6 June 2023, the Ministry of the Interior refused to grant refugee status and excluded him from subsidiary protection for committing a serious crime. The applicant appealed this decision before the Regional Court of Brno.
The court found the appeal unfounded. It held that the applicant's active participation in the PKK as a fighter did not constitute the exercise of political rights as participation in a non-state armed group cannot be subsumed under any constitutionally protected political right. The court noted that the PKK is regarded as a terrorist organisation by Türkiye and other states and is included on the EU sanctions list, and that active combat participation in such an organisation cannot enjoy human rights protection. The fact that the PKK's activities relate to the promotion of Kurdish minority rights did not change this.
While the risk of prosecution was not ruled out, the court noted that the prosecution of crimes related to the threat of terrorism may be considered legitimate in any country, and therefore cannot be considered as persecution in itself, provided that it is not carried out in a discriminatory or disproportionate manner. In the applicant's case, the court found that the prosecution would not be based on the applicant's political opinion but would be due to his participation in a terrorist organisation. Furthermore, it found no indication that there was a threat of discriminatory prosecution or punishment.
The applicant also argued that the asylum authority had failed to gather sufficient information regarding the treatment of PKK supporters in Türkiye. The court rejected this criticism, reasoning that once the authority had correctly concluded that there was no causal link between any potential harm and an asylum-relevant ground, further investigation into the treatment of PKK members was unnecessary for the asylum claim. Such information might have been relevant to subsidiary protection, but the court noted that the applicant had already been excluded from that form of protection.
Finally, the court considered the applicant's membership in the pro-Kurdish HDP political party and the DemKurd organisation. It acknowledged that membership in these groups constitutes an exercise of the right to freedom of association and may therefore involve protected political activity. However, the applicant had not demonstrated that he had undertaken any significant political activities on their behalf or that he would face persecution because of his membership. Country information showed that ordinary HDP members are not systematically persecuted and that risk generally arises only for individuals who engage in prominent political activism, public criticism of the government, or participation in demonstrations. The applicant had not established that he fell into any of these categories. Accordingly, the court found the applicant's objection to the refusal of asylum to be unfounded.
Following this, the court assessed whether the applicant should be excluded from subsidiary protection in accordance with Article 17(1)(b) of the recast Qualification Directive (QD). Relying on case law from the Supreme Administrative Court, it confirmed that ‘serious crime' is an autonomous concept of refugee law that cannot be equated with the ‘particularly serious crime' concept under the Czech criminal law which carries a maximum penalty of at least 10 years. While criminal law terminology may be taken into account to classify an act as a serious crime, it held that other criteria must be considered, such as the nature and seriousness of the act committed, the amount of the penalty associated to the crime, the applicant's degree of participating, whether the crime has not been committed (and if so, why), or the fact that the applicant has already served a prison sentence. In general, all mitigating and aggravating circumstances, and other subjective or objective circumstances, whether they occurred prior to or following the act, must be assessed when determining the seriousness of the crime.
It referred hereto to the relevancy of the CJEU ruling of Germany v B and D (C-57/09 and C-101/09, 9 November 2010) which requires that the exclusion of a person follows an individual examination of the specific facts. The Regional Court in Brno agreed with the reasoning of the Ministry of the Interior, ruling that all three offences were intentional and violent, with upper statutory limits of eight to ten years and prison sentences totalling almost seven years. It upheld the ministry's finding that while the criminal code only considers grievous bodily harm to be a particularly serious crime as it holds a maximum sentence of 10 years, all three offences can nevertheless be described as serious crimes for the purposes of exclusion, describing the acts as violent crime that suppresses the fundamental rights and freedoms of the victims.
The court also affirmed the ministry's findings on the domestic abuse conviction, which fulfilled the concept of a serious crime. It found that the applicant humiliated his wife for a long time, restricted her personal freedom and subjected her to physical and psychological violence and abuse. It furthermore noted that the seriousness of his actions is evidenced by the lengthy time and escalating nature of the violence, including when his wife was pregnant or when their children were present. Although the ministry noted the lenient sentence imposed on the applicant, it did not consider this element to be decisive in light of the serious nature and harm caused by the applicant. It found that the applicant's conduct towards his wife was aimed at total control and subjugation through the use of violent means and noted that his behaviour did not change even after his conviction. Concerning his conviction of grievous bodily harm, although the crime was an attempt, and the injured partied did not suffer serious harm, the ministry nevertheless considered that the crime was of a violent nature and a weapon was used, with the violence continuing even after one of the injured parties suffered a head injury. It considered that the crime was not completed by reason of coincidence, and not out of the intention of the applicant.
Furthermore, the court found that the fact that the applicant already served his sentence could not diminish the seriousness of the crime in light of its frequency, violent nature, and the absence of any self-reflection or remorse shown by the applicant.
The court held that applicant could not diminish the seriousness of the crime of domestic violence against his wife alleging cultural differences, since he had lived in the Czechia since 2008 and had ample time to adapt. Citing B and D and Shajin Ahmed (Afghanistan) v Immigration and Asylum Office (HU, Bevándorlási És Állampolgársági Hivatal) (C-369/17, 13 September 2018), the court held that whether the perpetrator poses a present danger to the host State is irrelevant to the application of the exclusion clause, so the ministry was not obliged to assess the applicant's current level of dangerousness.
Based on the above findings, the appeal was declared unfounded.