Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

​​

20/06/2024
BE: The Council for Alien Law Litigation ruled that country-of-origin information did not substantiate the existence of a particular social group of westernised returnees to Nigeria. It also confirmed the exclusion from subsidiary protection of a Nigerian applicant who was convicted for pimping and drug trafficking in Nigeria. Although it acknowledged that not all narcotic offences amount to a serious crime, it found that, in light of the nature and gravity of the acts, and the severe penalty imposed on the applicant, the crimes in question reached the requisite level of seriousness.
20/06/2024
BE: The Council for Alien Law Litigation ruled that country-of-origin information did not substantiate the existence of a particular social group of westernised returnees to Nigeria. It also confirmed the exclusion from subsidiary protection of a Nigerian applicant who was convicted for pimping and drug trafficking in Nigeria. Although it acknowledged that not all narcotic offences amount to a serious crime, it found that, in light of the nature and gravity of the acts, and the severe penalty imposed on the applicant, the crimes in question reached the requisite level of seriousness.

ECLI
Input Provided By
EUAA Information and Analysis Sector (IAS)
Other Source/Information
Type
Judgment
Original Documents
Relevant Legislative Provisions
European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR); Recast Qualification Directive (Directive 2011/95/EU on standards for the qualification of third-country nationals or stateless persons as BIP for a uniform status for refugees or for persons eligible for subsidiary protection)(recast QD)/or QD 2004/83/EC
Reference
Belgium, Council for Alien Law Litigation [Conseil du Contentieux des Étrangers - CALL], X v Commissioner General for Refugees and Stateless Persons (le Commissaire Général aux Réfugiés et aux Apatrides; de Commissaris-generaal voor de vluchtelingen en de staatlozen; CGRS; CGRA; CGVS), No. 308 627, 20 June 2024. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.
Permanent link to the case
https://caselaw.euaa.europa.eu/pages/viewcaselaw.aspx?CaseLawID=6000
Case history
Other information

Cited materials:

Cited case-law:

Abstract

A Nigerian national moved to Belgium with his family as a child in 2000 and obtained a permanent residence in 2010. Between 2014 and 2015 he was a leading member of a group that operated as a criminal organisation engaged in the exploitation of prostitution (including of minors), drug trafficking and violence. On 13 July 2016 the Brussels Criminal Court convicted him of leading a criminal organisation, pimping/exploitation of prostitution and drug trafficking, sentencing him to 78 months of imprisonment. His residence permit was terminated in 2018, a decision which was upheld on appeal and confirmed by the Council of State in June 2020. In May 2022 he lodged an application for international protection, claiming that he had no remaining ties to Nigeria, did not speak the language, and feared being stigmatised on return as someone who had missed his opportunity in Europe.


By decision of 15 December 2022, the CGRS refused refugee status, finding that the alleged fears could not be linked to any Convention ground and that ‘returnees' did not constitute a particular social group. It excluded the applicant from subsidiary protection for the commission of a serious crime and issued an opinion that removal was compatible with national law as no situation of indiscriminate violence affecting civilians was established in Lagos State.


On appeal, the applicant argued that the investigation of his claim had been inadequate as he had been interviewed in detention and felt destabilised, that he belonged to the social group of ‘returnees' and additionally feared persecution as a westernised Christian without a network, and that the exclusion clause should not apply. As regards the application of the exclusion grounds, he contended that a 78-month sentence did not denote a serious crime, that his individual responsibility was limited, and that account had to be taken of mitigating circumstances, his lack of recidivism, the fact that he had served his entire sentence, the eight years elapsed since the offences, his subsequent exemplary conduct, and a proportionality test between the gravity of the offences and the harm feared.


The Council for Aliens Law Litigation found the contested decision adequately reasoned.


It held that the two press articles relied upon by the applicant (both dating from 2020) were insufficient, outdated, bore no analogy to the applicant's individual situation, and failed to establish that Nigerians returning after a long stay in Europe are perceived as a distinct group so as to constitute a particular social group. The claims of being a westernised returnee, disabled and at risk as a Christian were found to be declaratory and unsubstantiated. The council also noted that the applicant's parents had never sought protection on these grounds and that his mother had returned to Nigeria without difficulty. It rejected the complaints concerning the investigation, observing that the applicant had been duly interviewed for one hour and forty minutes by a protection officer who travelled to his place of detention, that the interview notes disclosed no destabilisation or comprehension difficulty, and that his lawyer had raised no such concern.


On exclusion from subsidiary protection, the council recalled that ‘crime' under the Law of 15 December 1980 is an autonomous and generic concept distinct from the Belgian criminal law, requiring a certain threshold of gravity. Relying on the CJEU ruling of Shajin Ahmed (Afghanistan) v Immigration and Asylum Office (HU, Bevándorlási És Állampolgársági Hivatal) (C-369/17, 13 September 2018), it reiterated that the seriousness of a crime under Article 17(1)(b) of the recast QD must be assessed against the following factors: the nature of the act, the harm caused, the procedure used for prosecution, the penalty incurred, and whether most jurisdictions also regard the act as serious. It also affirmed that exclusion requires an individual assessment of the specific facts and cannot be automatic. The council emphasised, following the ruling of the CJEU, that the scope of Article 17(1)(b) is broader than that of Article 1F(b) of the Geneva Convention, being limited neither geographically, nor temporally, nor as to the nature of the crimes, while remaining of strict interpretation. It referred to the EASO Judicial Analysis: Exclusion - Articles 12 and 17 Qualification Directive, second edition (2020), which lists drug trafficking among examples of serious crimes, and to the relevant UNHCR guidance.


The council found that the administrative file contained enough material to interpret the nature of the acts committed, in particular the criminal judgment imposing a sentence of 78 months, and that the facts of the judgment had been acknowledged by the applicant when questioned by the CGRS and again admitted at the hearing. The council further noted that the conviction itself had stressed the gravity of the acts and upheld the CGRS's finding that it emerged sufficiently from the judgment and the applicant's own statements that there were serious reasons to consider he had both the intention and the knowledge required to commit the crimes in question.


As to the weight of the sentence, the council confirmed that the severity of the penalty pronounced is only one element among others in assessing the gravity of the acts. It observed that, although the applicant emphasised that he had received only 78 months, the penalties to which he had been exposed for the crimes committed were particularly severe. The fact that a lesser sentence was actually imposed did not diminish that severity.


The court acknowledged that not all narcotic offences can be classified as meeting the seriousness threshold and must be assessed on a case by case basis. In the applicant's case, the court found that the requisite level of seriousness was reached by taking into account the nature of the offences (trafficking in marijuana, cannabis and cocaine), his leadership position, the length of the offending period (July 2014 to December 2015), and the severe penalty to which the applicant had been exposed (ten to fifteen years).


Concerning the offence of pimping, the council held that the applicant's conviction as an accomplice rather than as the perpetrator of the act did not diminish his individual responsibility, particularly as minors were involved, a fact which he could have been reasonably aware of, regardless of whether he personally exploited the minors. It considered that his conviction of prostitution of an adult, under particular circumstances, could not constitute grounds for exoneration of the seriousness of the pimping.


The council rejected the arguments based on mitigating circumstances, expiation and proportionality. Citing the CJEU ruling of Germany v B and D (C-57/09 and C-101/09, 9 November 2010), it held that exclusion does not require a separate proportionality assessment, and that neither the texts of Articles 55/2 and 55/4 of the Law of 15 December 1980 nor the relevant international instruments provide for grounds of expiation capable of precluding exclusion. The court noted that despite the fact that UNHCR guidance considers that expiation factors should be taken into account, the guidance cannot take precedence over the Geneva Convention which, according to the court, does not require the crime to remain unexpiated, nor does it attach significance to expressions of remorse, a sentence served, amnesty or pardon.


Finally, the council declared inadmissible the plea alleging a violation of Article 3 of the ECHR, holding that it was not seized of a removal measure and therefore lacked competence to rule on the lawfulness of removal.


The appeal was thus declared unfounded.


Country of Decision
Belgium
Court Name
BE: Council for Alien Law Litigation [Conseil du Contentieux des Étrangers - CALL]
Case Number
No. 308 627
Date of Decision
20/06/2024
Country of Origin
Nigeria
Keywords
Assessment of applications
Assessment of evidence/assessment of documents
Country of Origin Information (COI)
EUAA Materials
EUAA Judicial Analysis / EUAA Professional Development Series
Exclusion
Grounds negating individual responsibility
Individual responsibility
Direct commission of an excludable act
Serious (non-political) crime
Convicted for a serious crime after arrival (subsidiary protection)
Specific circumstances subsequent to an excludable act
Served sentence
Refugee status/protection
Membership of a particular social group
Vulnerable group
Applicant with disabilities