On 3 September 2019, the State Secretary for Justice and Security, rejected the subsequent asylum application of an Iranian national on account of serious reasons to believe that he had been guilty of serious non-political crimes in his home country. It noted that together with his two friends, he raped a boy and a girl in Iran on 1 April 2014. An appeal lodged by the applicant was declared unfounded by the District Court of the Hague, seated in Rotterdam, on 4 December 2020. The applicant lodged a further appeal before the Council of State.
The applicant argued that he cannot be held individually responsible for the crime, as due to his psychological condition at the time of the crime, he could not comprehend what he was doing. He argued that in light of the evidence that he submitted, the state secretary should have conducted further research into his psychological condition. He argued that he has had psychological issues since he was eighteen years old, which led him to self-harm, and on several occasions, he attempted suicide which led to hospitalisations. The applicant also argued that his psychological condition led him to use narcotics, and that he was under the influence when committing the crime. He also noted that he was exempt from military service in Iran due to his mental state, and to support this statement, he submitted a statement by the Military Commission dated 26 November 2012 on appeal.
The Council of State upheld the appeal, finding that the district court wrongly considered that the state secretary had properly substantiated its decision that the applicant could be held individually responsible for committing a crime under Article 1F(b) of the Geneva Convention. The council noted that the statement of the military commission contained a medical diagnosis drawn by a committee consisting of doctors and/or psychiatrists, which diagnosed the applicant with borderline personality disorder. The council considered that the fact that the applicant did not submit any other medical documents did not change this. Additionally, it did not accept the argument that the dating of the medical evidence failed to provide clarity about the psychological condition of the applicant at the time of the crime.
The council found that the state secretary failed to account for the nature of the personality disorder in its decision, and did not address the applicant's statements with regards to his psychological condition, including his statement that he had made another suicide attempt shortly after the crimes had been committed. Furthermore, it held that the fact the applicant stated he was under the influence of narcotics at the time of the crime does not preclude the state secretary from conducting further investigation, as the applicant had undisputable stated that the use of these substances followed from his psychological condition.
Additionally, the council found that the state secretary failed to explain why the fact that rape may lead to the imposition of the death penalty under Iranian law does not preclude his deportation.
The appeal was declared well founded. The decision of the district court was set aside, and the decision of the state secretary was annulled.