Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

​​

19/12/2024
NL: The District Court of the Hague, seated in Rotterdam, ruled that by marrying a thirteen year old girl when he was twenty-six years old, a Syrian national had committed a serious non-political crime. It also considered that even if such an act may not be considered a serious crime in the applicant’s country of origin, what matters for the purposes of applying the exclusion clauses is international consensus that the conduct is a serious crime.
19/12/2024
NL: The District Court of the Hague, seated in Rotterdam, ruled that by marrying a thirteen year old girl when he was twenty-six years old, a Syrian national had committed a serious non-political crime. It also considered that even if such an act may not be considered a serious crime in the applicant’s country of origin, what matters for the purposes of applying the exclusion clauses is international consensus that the conduct is a serious crime.

ECLI
ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2024:22063
Input Provided By
EUAA Exclusion Network
Other Source/Information
Type
Judgment
Original Documents
Relevant Legislative Provisions
UN International Covenants / UN Conventions
Reference
Netherlands, Court of The Hague [Rechtbank Den Haag], Applicant v The Minister for Asylum and Migration (de Minister van Asiel en Migratie), NL24.22620, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2024:22063, 19 December 2024. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.
Permanent link to the case
https://caselaw.euaa.europa.eu/pages/viewcaselaw.aspx?CaseLawID=5897
Case history
Other information

European Union, Court of Justice of the European Union [CJEU], Germany v B and D, C-57/09 and C-101/09, EU:C:2010:661, 09 November 2010. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.

Abstract

A Syrian national applied for international protection on 10 October 2022. The Minister for Asylum and Migration rejected the application as manifestly unfounded on 23 May 2024. It considered that the applicant had committed a serious non-political crime within the meaning of Article 1(F) of the Geneva Convention by marrying a thirteen year old girl with whom he had sex almost directly after. He was registered with the Schengen Information System (SIS) for 10 years as the minister found that his conduct constituted a present and sufficiently serious threat to a fundamental interest of society. He appealed this decision before the District Court of the Hague, seated in Rotterdam.


The district court set out the applicable legal framework, with reference to Article 1F(b) of the Geneva Convention and paragraph C2/7.10.2.2 of the Aliens Circular 2000 (Vc 2000). It held that when assessing the seriousness of a crime, the maximum penalty imposed on the offence according to the Dutch criminal code is an importance consideration, however it is not a decisive element, and a full investigation and assessment of all relevant facts remains necessary to assess that a crime constitutes s a serious non-political crime. It recalled that an international standard and consensus as to whether the crime can be qualified as serious is required, and can be derived from different sources such as UNHCR guidelines, international treaties, European Union law, resolutions of the UN Security Council, and resolutions, conclusions or other statements of European Institutions. It also referred to European and international case law and legislation, implementation and legal practice of other countries. The court also referred to Article 19(1) of the Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) which obligates states to take measures to protect children from all forms of physical and mental violence.


The applicant argued that he did not commit a serious non-political crime, as the minister had wrongly assumed that there is international consensus that child marriages relate to a serious crime. He argued that the international instruments referenced by the minister refer to the protection of children against sexual exploitation and sexual abuse, and do not rule explicitly on child marriages. The applicant asserted that the arab perspective differs from a western European perspective, and that child marriages are not viewed as sexual exploitation especially when both parties have voluntarily consented to the marriage. He argued that his marriage to a thirteen-year-old is allowed under certain conditions in Syria, and noted that sex within marriage is allowed. he also pointed out on the basis of country information that Syrian legislation to prevent child marriage was only revised in 2021, while the applicant married his wife in 2014, in accordance with the acceptable social and cultural norms at that time.


The court dismissed the appeal. It considered that the minister was correct to consider that consummation of the tradition marriage by the applicant, who was a twenty six year old man, with a thirteen year old, is by its nature a very serious crime in light of the serious physical and mental violation of integration of the child and the long term adverse psychological consequences. The court noted that in view of their age, minors must be protected against people who wants to sexually abuse them, and that the consent of the minor does not justify the crime, especially considering that a thirteen year old may not be capable of guarding their sexual integrity and resisting an adult. It held that even though the parents of the applicant's wife agreed to the marriage and that she had been prepared by her mother for the consummation of the marriage and that she would have wanted to proceed, this does not lead to a different conclusion, as even under such circumstance the  crime remains very serious by its nature.


Furthermore, the court noted that sex with a thirteen year old is punishable in both Syria and the Netherlands. In Syria, the court observed that sex with a minor under the age of fifteen is punishable by a sentence of nine years of forced labour, while in the Netherlands, the maximum penalty for the crime is twelve years and qualifies as rape. The court noted that in view of this high maximum penalty, the minister was right to conclude that the applicant's conduct constitutes a serious crime within the meaning of the Geneva convention.


Additionally, the court agreed with the minister's position that there is international consensus that sex with a thirteen year old is considered a serious crime. It referred to Article 19 of the CRC, the aforementioned criminalisation of the crime in both the Netherlands and Syria, and noted that this consensus is also reflected in national and international legal practice, such as case law from the Council of Aliens Law Litigation in Belgium. It also observed that marriages with children under the age of fifteen are not permitted in most arab countries, and that even if sex with a minor under the age of fifteen in a traditional marriage in Syria would not be considered a serious crime, that conduct may nevertheless constitute a ground for exclusion from international protection  in the light of the established international consensus. Hereto, the court referred to the EUAA Country Guidance: Syria Common analysis and guidance note (September 2020).


Following this, the court assessed whether there was ‘knowing participation'. In this regard, it noted that pursuant to paragraph C2/7.10.2.4(c) of the Vc 2000, there is knowing participation when the applicant participates in acts for which he knew or should have known that they concerned crimes as referred to in Article 1F. The court considered that having sex with a thirteen-year-old is also punishable in Syria and that the applicant was expected to have been aware of this. Based on his statements, the court noted that the applicant was aware of the applicants age at the time of the marriage and was aware of her vulnerability and the dominance that he had over her as an adult man. Therefore, it considered that he was aware of the inappropriate nature of his behaviour, however, he acted out of choice to have sex with a child, although he could have opted not to.


With reference to the CJEU ruling in Germany v B and D (C-57/09 and C-101/09, 9 November 2010), the court noted that a proportionality assessment is not required when applying Article 12(2) of the QD. However, the district court held that in its opinion, this does not mean that in a case such as the present one, where Article 1F is invoked, there is no room at all for a proportionality assessment. Nevertheless, it highlighted that the scope of such an assessment is limited, and the invocation of Article 1F can only be disproportionate in very exceptional circumstances.


The court considered that in light of the seriousness of the crime, the passage of time (10 years since the marriage took place) was of only marginal significance. It considered that it follows from the nature of such a serious crime that it remains topical for a very long time, and that this was not affected by the legal registration of the marriage in November 2020. It upheld the position of the minister that as a result of the child marriage and its consummation, the relationship between the applicant and his wife can he characterised as a highly dependent one, and therefore, the unilateral statements by the applicant that they are monogamous, happily married, and have five children, have no bearing on the proportionality of the application of the exclusion clause.


The court thus declared the appeal unfounded.


Country of Decision
Netherlands
Court Name
NL: Court of The Hague [Rechtbank Den Haag]
Case Number
NL24.22620
Date of Decision
19/12/2024
Country of Origin
Syria
Keywords
EUAA Materials
EUAA Country Guidance Materials
Exclusion
Individual responsibility
Direct commission of an excludable act
Modes of individual responsibility
State of mind
Serious (non-political) crime
Commission of a serious non-political crime outside the country of refuge prior to admission as a refugee
Forced marriage/Child marriage