Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

​​

14/05/2024
FR: The Council of State ruled that when assessing whether an applicant should be excluded from international protection, their motives for committing a war crime are irrelevant. The council found serious reasons to believe that a Russian national of Chechen origin had committed war crimes during the Chechen wars by carrying out intelligence missions that led to the arrest and torture or execution of Chechen civilians.
14/05/2024
FR: The Council of State ruled that when assessing whether an applicant should be excluded from international protection, their motives for committing a war crime are irrelevant. The council found serious reasons to believe that a Russian national of Chechen origin had committed war crimes during the Chechen wars by carrying out intelligence missions that led to the arrest and torture or execution of Chechen civilians.

ECLI
ECLI:FR:CECHR:2024:463491.20240514
Input Provided By
EUAA Information and Analysis Sector (IAS)
Other Source/Information
Type
Judgment
Original Documents
Relevant Legislative Provisions
UN International Covenants / UN Conventions
Reference
France, Council of State [Conseil d'État], French Office for the Protection of Refugees and Stateless Persons (Office Français de Protection des Réfugiés et Apatrides‚ OFPRA) v Applicants, 463491, ECLI:FR:CECHR:2024:463491.20240514, 14 May 2024. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.
Permanent link to the case
https://caselaw.euaa.europa.eu/pages/viewcaselaw.aspx?CaseLawID=5873
Case history
Other information
Abstract

On 27 May 2020, the Director General of the French Office for the Protection of Refugees and Stateless Persons (OFPRA), rejected the applications for international protection of a husband and wife who were Russian nationals with Chechen origin. The decisions were annulled by the National Court of Asylum (CNDA) on 24 February 2022, and they were granted refugee status. The OFPRA appealed against the decision of the CNDA before the Council of State.


The council began by recalling the legal framework governing refugee status, as defined by the 1951 Geneva Convention and its 1967 Protocol. It noted that refugee status depends on a well-founded fear of persecution, but it is subject to exclusion clauses, particularly Article 1(F), which denies protection to individuals suspected of having committed crimes against peace, war crimes or crimes against humanity, serious non-political crimes, or acts contrary to the principles of the United Nations. It noted that Article 1(F) applies to persons who were instigators, accomplices or were personally involved in the excludable acts laid out in the provision. It held that to exclude an applicant under Article 1(F), there must be serious reasons for considering that the applicant was personally responsible for the crime attributed to him through their personal involvement in such crimes or acts. It noted that an accomplice, as defined by the French national asylum law, refers to a person who through their actions have knowingly contributed to the preparation or commission of the crime or has facilitates its commission, or was present at the time of an execution without seekers, depending on their situation, to prevent it or dissociate oneself from it.


The council then specified the meaning of war crimes under Article 1(F)(a), referring to international humanitarian law, including the Geneva Conventions of 1949 and their additional protocols, as well as Article 8 of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. These crimes include acts such as killing civilians, torture, or mistreatment of prisoners, and cannot be justified by the objectives pursued by those committing them. In this regard, the council held that the CNDA should not have taken into account the alleged legitimacy or purpose of the violence when assessing whether exclusion should apply. It held that such reasoning constitutes an error of law, since the classification of war crimes is independent of the perpetrator's motives as derived from the above-mentioned international law framework.


Turning to the facts of the case, the council found that the CNDA also erred in its assessment of the husband's conduct. The record showed that he participated in both Chechen wars, first in a logistical capacity and later as a combatant under the command of Dokou Oumarov, founder of the Islamist terrorist organisation "Emirate of the Caucasus". His role included intelligence missions that led to the arrest, and subsequent torture or execution of Chechen civilians accused of being ‘traitors', roles which the OPFRA found that he tried to minimise. The council noted that the applicant was aware of the consequences of his actions, did not express regret, and even claimed responsibility for them, without attempting to distance himself from these acts. By concluding that there were no serious reasons to believe that the applicant had committed or been complicit in such acts, comparable to war crimes, the council found that the CNDA mischaracterised the facts.


Consequently, the Council of State concluded that OFPRA's appeal was well-founded. It annulled the decision of the CNDA and referred the case back for reconsideration.


Country of Decision
France
Court Name
FR: Council of State [Conseil d'État]
Case Number
463491
Date of Decision
14/05/2024
Country of Origin
Russia
Keywords
Assessment of applications
Exclusion
Individual responsibility
Aiding and abetting
Direct commission of an excludable act
Modes of individual responsibility
War crime