Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

​​

02/06/2020
DK: The Refugee Appeals Board overturned the exclusion decision concerning a former major in the Syrian army, finding that the applicant refused orders and forbade his unit from committing violent acts against civilians in a context in which the Syrian army was systematically killing and detaining demonstrators and other civilians in 2011.
02/06/2020
DK: The Refugee Appeals Board overturned the exclusion decision concerning a former major in the Syrian army, finding that the applicant refused orders and forbade his unit from committing violent acts against civilians in a context in which the Syrian army was systematically killing and detaining demonstrators and other civilians in 2011.

ECLI
Input Provided By
EUAA Information and Analysis Sector (IAS)
Other Source/Information
Type
Judgment
Original Documents
Relevant Legislative Provisions
UN International Covenants / UN Conventions
Reference
Denmark, Refugee Appeals Board [Flygtningenævnet], Syri/2020/9/DH, syri20209, 02 June 2020. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.
Permanent link to the case
https://caselaw.euaa.europa.eu/pages/viewcaselaw.aspx?CaseLawID=5858
Case history
Other information
Abstract

The Refugee Appeals Board overturned  the decision of the Immigration Service which excluded a Syrian national from international protection. In connection with his request for asylum, the applicant stated that he entered the Syrian Military Academy in 1996, and after three years of training, he was assigned to the Syrian's army special forces. In 2011, while stationed in the province of Tartous, he was given the order to suppress demonstrations, however, he refused the order to shoot at civilians and forbade his platoon from doing so. In autumn that same year, while stationed in Homs, the applicant and his unit carried out house searches of civilians to search for weapons and wanted persons. The applicant was detained by the intelligence service for 10 days and subjected to interrogation and physical abuse during the detention on account of not having followed military orders, including by preventing several attacks on civilians during the searches. Once released, he was transferred multiple times for four months between different departments and imprisoned again for two and a half years on the same grounds. After his release, he fled the army and became the frontman of two-armed groups whose objectives were to protect civilians from attacks by the Syrian authorities, before eventually leaving his home country. 


Despite country information showing that in 2011 the Syrian army systematically carried out the killing and arbitrary arrest of demonstrators and other civilians, the board found that the applicant did not contribute to such crimes while serving as a major and being stationed in Tartous and Homs in 2014, as his actions demonstrated that he actively tried to prevent violence against civilians which consequently led to his imprisonment. Specifically, the board noted that neither the applicant nor the people in his unit participated in violence and assaults against civilians. On the contrary,  they prevented the intelligence services on several occasions from such acts. Although the board assumed that in some cases , the intelligence service carried out the burning of civilian residences and robberies while conducting the house searches which the applicant took part in, it held that there was no basis for assuming that there was a risk of personal injury in relation to these burnings. Therefore, it concluded that these circumstances could not be characterised as a serious non-political crime for the purposes of exclusion. The board granted the applicant a residence permit pursuant to section 7(1) of the Aliens Act also on grounds that the Syrian authorities had continued to visit the residence of the applicant's family since his unlawful departure from Syria. 


Country of Decision
Denmark
Court Name
DK: Refugee Appeals Board [Flygtningenævnet]
Case Number
syri20209
Date of Decision
02/06/2020
Country of Origin
Syria
Keywords
Exclusion
Grounds negating individual responsibility
Serious (non-political) crime
Refugee status/protection
Military service / Conscientious objection / Desertion / Draft evasion / Forced conscription