Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

​​

23/01/2025
DK: The Refugee Appeals Board overturned the exclusion decision of an Afghan applicant who worked with the Afghan Security Services between 2017-2021 and was involved in the arrest of Taliban members. It found that although the applicant was involved in arrests, he was not aware that the detainees were sometimes tortured during interrogations and country of origin information did not provide conclusive evidence of the extent to which torture was used at the applicant’s place of work.
23/01/2025
DK: The Refugee Appeals Board overturned the exclusion decision of an Afghan applicant who worked with the Afghan Security Services between 2017-2021 and was involved in the arrest of Taliban members. It found that although the applicant was involved in arrests, he was not aware that the detainees were sometimes tortured during interrogations and country of origin information did not provide conclusive evidence of the extent to which torture was used at the applicant’s place of work.

ECLI
Input Provided By
EUAA Information and Analysis Sector (IAS)
Other Source/Information
Type
Judgment
Original Documents
Relevant Legislative Provisions
UN International Covenants / UN Conventions
Reference
Denmark, Refugee Appeals Board [Flygtningenævnet], afgh20252, Afgh/2025/2/sahe, 23 January 2025. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.
Permanent link to the case
https://caselaw.euaa.europa.eu/pages/viewcaselaw.aspx?CaseLawID=5856
Case history
Other information
Abstract

In January 2025, the Danish Refugee Appeals Board overturned a decision excluding an Afghan national from international protection and granted him a residence permit.


The applicant submitted to the board that he worked in his home country since 2017 with the Afghan Security Service until the Taliban took power in 2021, being assigned to a sub-section of the national security unit which and having been involved in the arrest of many Taliban members. He feared that upon return to Afghanistan he would be killed by the Taliban as revenge for the arrests he was involved in during his employment. He claimed that the Taliban possessed information on all individuals who worked with the Afghan authorities and for the security service. In this regard, he reported that they looked for him after he fled and detained his father, causing him injuries which led to his death. On this basis, the board agreed with the Immigration Service that the applicant was entitled to international protection under Section 7(1) of the Aliens Act.


Nevertheless, contrary to the finding of the Immigration Service, the board considered that the exclusion grounds were not applicable in the applicant's case. It highlighted that it could be assumed that the applicant did not participate in interrogations where torture was used, and that he was not aware of the use of torture by the section of the security services which handled the further processing of individuals following their arrest. Although the applicant stated that he had a general perception that torture could occur since Afghanistan is a ‘third world country', he explained that torture was prohibited by the law, and he was informed of this during his training upon taking up the position with the security services. The board corroborated this explanation with country of origin information (COI).


The board first noted that the acts under assessment were not covered by the concept of ‘crimes against humanity' within the meaning of Article 1F(a) of the Refugee Convention as the abuses were not committed within the framework of systematic attacks against the civilian population. Turning to the applicability of Article 1 F(b) of the Refugee Convention, which concerns serious non-political crimes, the board emphasised that such provisions must be applied restrictively, the burden of proof falls with the authorities and the standard of proof required ‘serious grounds to believe' that the applicant committed a serious non-political crime. The board recalled the guidance provided by UNHCR's Background Note on the Application of the Exclusion Clauses, which emphasised the necessity of an assessment of the individual responsibility of the applicant and clarifies the different modes of contribution to excludable acts, including both direct and indirect commission.


Applying this framework to the present case, the board noted that available COI did not ascertain whether and to what extent torture was used at the applicant's place of work. Also, COI reports showed a decrease in the use of torture in Afghanistan since 2011 as well as large variations of the practice in different provinces. It noted that specifically in the applicant's province, 7 people out of 42 reported that they were subjected to torture between 2017-2018. Based on this information, the board concluded that the applicant did not necessarily have the knowledge that the persons whom he helped to arrest would be subjected to torture, especially taking into account his subordinate position, his lack of participation in interrogations in which torture was used, and his lack of knowledge on the working methods of the other sections of the security service.


In light of the above, the board concluded that there were no serious grounds to believe that the applicant committed a serious non-political crime, and granted him a residence permit under Section 7(1) of the Aliens Act.


Country of Decision
Denmark
Court Name
DK: Refugee Appeals Board [Flygtningenævnet]
Case Number
Afgh/2025/2/sahe
Date of Decision
23/01/2025
Country of Origin
Afghanistan
Keywords
Burden of proof
Exclusion
Individual responsibility
State of mind
Serious (non-political) crime
Commission of a serious non-political crime outside the country of refuge prior to admission as a refugee
Standard of proof