A Syrian national applied for asylum on 26 October 2016. He stated that he served for three and a half years in the Syrian army as a vehicle driver and checkpoint guard, where his role was primarily to report or hand over registered individuals to the security service or military police. After being injured several times he decided to desert the military in April 2015. He left Syria illegally via the Syria-Türkiye border after having used a forged Syrian identity card.
On 12 April 2018 the State Secretariat for Migration (SEM) issued a decision recognising the applicant as a refugee but denying him asylum under Article 53 of the Swiss Asylum Act (AsylG). The SEM concluded that he was unworthy of asylum due to alleged reprehensible acts connected to his military service. As a result, the authority ordered his expulsion from Switzerland. However, because removal to Syria was considered inadmissible, the enforcement of the expulsion order was suspended and the applicant was granted provisional admission. The applicant subsequently appealed this decision to the Federal Administrative Court, claiming that the SEM insufficiently investigated the relevant facts.
The Federal Administrative Court outlined the relevant legal framework. Under Article 2(1) of the AsylG, Switzerland generally grants asylum to refugees. Nevertheless, Article 53 provides exceptions for refugees who are deemed unworthy of asylum because they committed reprehensible acts or because they have endangered Switzerland's internal or external security. The court explained that Swiss asylum jurisprudence interprets ‘reprehensible acts' in reference to serious criminal offenses comparable to crimes under Swiss criminal law, meaning offenses punishable by more than three years. The court emphasised that the classification depends on the maximum penalty prescribed by law rather than the sentence actually imposed. Importantly, strict proof of crimes committed abroad is not required in asylum proceedings; it is sufficient to establish that serious grounds exist to believe the individual committed such acts. The authorities must examine the individual's specific role and responsibility. Mere membership in an extremist or violent organisation is not sufficient by itself to justify exclusion from asylum. Instead, decision-makers must assess the seriousness of the conduct, the individual's contribution, motives, possible justifications, and whether exclusion would be proportionate.
Before assessing the applicant's conduct, the court examined the broader political and human rights context in Syria during the relevant period. It referred to previous jurisprudence establishing that since March 2011 Syrian state security forces had responded to actual or alleged opponents of the regime with extreme brutality. Numerous reports documented arrests, torture, and arbitrary killings of a large number of demonstrators. The unrest had been triggered in part by events in the city of Dar'a in March 2011, where state security forces arrested children and killed several demonstrators during subsequent protests. The regime's increasingly violent repression of protests, which included hundreds of deaths and the detention and torture of tens of thousands of people, eventually escalated into a full-scale civil war.
After examining these facts, the Federal Administrative Court concluded that there were no concrete indications that the applicant had committed a serious criminal offence or any other reprehensible act within the meaning of Article 53 of the Asylum Act. The court found that the file showed he had performed only subordinate support functions within the Syrian army. His testimony did not indicate that he directly participated in acts of violence. The court rejected the SEM's position that his allegedly evasive statements justified assuming involvement in crimes. In particular, the SEM had not demonstrated conclusively how the applicant could have contributed to the violent and homicidal crimes of the Syrian army. It dismissed as inadmissible the SEM's presumption that the applicant was jointly responsibility for the crimes of which the Syrian army was accused. The court considered that by asserting that it was surprising that the applicant took part in military and weapons training but he has never used a weapon himself, the SEM imputed the applicant a general complicity in the crimes attributed to the Syrian army. The court found no evidence of participating in a concrete act that would be characterised as a significant contribution to a crime.
The court ruled that it can only be speculated what the effects of the applicant's support activities, including transporting people and food and guarding checkpoints, would be. It held that it could not be ruled out that these activities could have contributed to the achievement of the goals of the Syrian army, especially in light of the long duration of this support. However, the available evidence did not demonstrate that these activities constituted a significant contribution to specific criminal acts. Even under the lower evidentiary standard applicable to crimes committed abroad, the record did not provide serious grounds to assume that the applicant had been involved in acts qualifying as reprehensible conduct under Article 53 of the AsylG. Accordingly, both direct and indirect participation in such acts had to be ruled out.
In light of these findings, the court concluded that the applicant could not be accused of any concrete and individual contribution to reprehensible acts. The court allowed the appeal, annulled the relevant sections of the SEM's decision, and instructed the SEM to grant the applicant asylum.