Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

​​

29/11/2022
CH: The Federal Administrative Court held that a Sri Lankan applicant could not be excluded from asylum under Article 53 of the Swiss Asylum Act because the available evidence did not establish that he had made a specific and individual contribution to reprehensible acts committed by the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE). Although he had been a member of the organisation and had worked as a trainer and intelligence officer, the court found that he had not participated directly or indirectly in violent or criminal acts.
29/11/2022
CH: The Federal Administrative Court held that a Sri Lankan applicant could not be excluded from asylum under Article 53 of the Swiss Asylum Act because the available evidence did not establish that he had made a specific and individual contribution to reprehensible acts committed by the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE). Although he had been a member of the organisation and had worked as a trainer and intelligence officer, the court found that he had not participated directly or indirectly in violent or criminal acts.

ECLI
Input Provided By
EUAA Information and Analysis Sector (IAS)
Other Source/Information
Type
Judgment
Original Documents
Relevant Legislative Provisions
National law only (in case there is no reference to EU law/ECHR)
Reference
Switzerland, Federal Administrative Court [Bundesverwaltungsgericht - Tribunal administratif fédéral - FAC], Applicant v State Secretariat for Migration (Staatssekretariat für Migration‚ SEM), D-6231/2019, 29 November 2022. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.
Permanent link to the case
https://caselaw.euaa.europa.eu/pages/viewcaselaw.aspx?CaseLawID=5852
Case history
Other information
Abstract

A Sri Lankan national of Tamil ethnicity applied for asylum in Switzerland on 4 October 2016. The applicant explained that his family had strong links to the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE): two of his brothers had served as high-ranking commanders within the organisation, both holding the rank of lieutenant-colonel, and both were killed during the Sri Lankan civil war. The applicant stated that his childhood had been shaped by the war, which led him to join the LTTE in 2005. After joining, he received military training and was promoted to the position of ‘training master' between 2005 and 2007. In this role, he trained recruits in physical exercises, rifle handling and basic tactics. Later he was transferred to the intelligence division of the LTTE, where he worked until December 2008. Within that structure he reported to a superior who herself reported to the head of the intelligence service.


In August 2008, the applicant was sent from the LTTE-controlled Vanni region to the city of Vavuniya. His mission, together with a colleague, was to observe movements of the Sri Lankan Army (SLA). He gathered information about troop movements, the transportation of weapons and military vehicles, and potential vulnerabilities that might enable attacks aimed at stopping or weakening the army's major offensive against LTTE forces. Some information was allegedly obtained through contacts with soldiers of the Sri Lankan Army. Shortly afterwards, the applicant's colleague in the intelligence department was killed by the Sri Lankan Army. The applicant believed that the army had learned about him through this colleague. Soon afterwards, members of the army tracked and followed him, but he managed to evade capture. His superior advised him to go into hiding and to leave the country. After several attempts, he escaped by boat to India in December 2008. The applicant maintained that if he were returned to Sri Lanka he would face a serious danger because the Sri Lankan authorities continue to pursue former LTTE intelligence members, fearing that they might contribute to a resurgence of the organisation. He also argued that his profile was particularly high due to the prominent role played by his two deceased brothers in the LTTE.


The State Secretariat for Migration (SEM) issued a decision on 23 October 2019. The SEM acknowledged that the applicant met the definition of a refugee under the Swiss Asylum Act, concluding that there was a considerable probability he would face persecution if returned to Sri Lanka. Nevertheless, the SEM rejected his asylum request on the ground that he was unworthy of asylum under Article 53 of the Asylum Act because of alleged reprehensible acts. At the same time, the SEM ordered his expulsion from Switzerland but suspended its execution due to inadmissibility, granting him provisional admission instead.


In its reasoning, the SEM argued that the applicant had likely been involved in armed combat operations during his time as a ‘training master' and that his activities could amount to criminal conduct. Even if no deaths or injuries could be directly attributed to him, the SEM considered that an attempted criminal offence could still be presumed. It noted that the LTTE had committed numerous serious acts of violence and human rights abuses. While the SEM acknowledged that mere membership in the organisation was insufficient to establish reprehensible acts under Article 53 of the Asylum Act, it emphasised the applicant's individual role. According to the SEM, his responsibilities as a training instructor and later as an intelligence operative indicated a substantial contribution to the LTTE's military operations. It also stressed that he had voluntarily joined the organisation as an adult and maintained close connections with senior LTTE figures, particularly his brothers. Furthermore, the SEM considered that he had never distanced himself from the LTTE, noting that he had continued to participate in events associated with the organisation after arriving in Switzerland and appeared to remain ideologically aligned with it. In assessing proportionality, the SEM acknowledged that the applicant would still be allowed to remain in Switzerland as a recognised refugee, but without the formal grant of asylum. The main practical consequence, in its view, would be limitations on family reunification with his wife. The SEM concluded that this restriction did not make the exclusion from asylum disproportionate.


The applicant appealed this decision before the Swiss Federal Administrative Court. The court recalled that Switzerland generally grants asylum to refugees under Article 2 (1) of the Asylum Act. However, Article 53 of the Act provides that refugees may be excluded from asylum if they are considered unworthy due to reprehensible acts or if they have violated or endangered Switzerland's internal or external security. The court clarified that ‘reprehensible acts' under Article 53 include offences corresponding to serious crimes under the Swiss criminal law, namely offences punishable by a maximum sentence exceeding three years' imprisonment. According to established jurisprudence, it is irrelevant whether such offences are of a common-law nature or politically motivated. The court also noted that strict proof of crimes committed abroad is not required. Instead, it is sufficient that there are serious reasons for assuming the individual committed such offences. At the same time, membership in an extremist organisation alone cannot justify exclusion from asylum. Authorities must determine the applicant's individual contribution to the alleged acts, considering factors such as the seriousness of the offence, the person's role in deciding to commit it, the motives involved, and any mitigating circumstances. Even when reprehensible acts are established, the exclusion must also be proportionate.


After reviewing the case, the Federal Administrative Court reached a different conclusion from the SEM. It held that the applicant could not be accused of making a specific and individual contribution to reprehensible acts within the meaning of Article 53 of the Asylum Act. The court first reiterated its established jurisprudence regarding the LTTE. It stated that the organisation cannot be regarded purely as a terrorist criminal group because it pursued the political objective of Tamil self-determination. However, due to the methods it used and the serious human rights violations associated with them, the LTTE also cannot be treated solely as a conventional civil war party. The court held that the LTTE activities could not be generally qualified as acts of war and that the mere fact of membership does not automatically justify exclusion. Instead, each case required an individualised assessment.


The court also referred to earlier case law illustrating situations when exclusion from asylum may be justified. It has previously affirmed unworthiness for asylum where individuals directly participated in combat operations, exercised command authority, managed weapons depots, or supplied combat units with weapons. By contrast, asylum has been granted in cases where individuals, either as members or sympathisers, carried out logistical or support roles, such as procuring materials, hiding or storing weapons or mines, collecting funds, working in the radio departments, repairing vehicles, or transporting people or food.


Applying these principles to the present case, the court concluded that the available evidence did not show that the applicant had participated directly or indirectly in violent or terrorist acts of the LTTE. His membership in the organisation and his roles as a trainer and intelligence worker did not in themselves amount to reprehensible acts. The court emphasised that the case file contained no clear indication that he had personally taken part in acts of violence. He had not held a leadership role, nor did he possess decision-making authority. According to FAC, the SEM had also failed to demonstrate concretely how his activities could be linked to specific violent offences.


Regarding his role as a training instructor, the court noted that the applicant had explained that he provided physical training, basic weapons training and tactical instruction to recruits, and that trainees practiced shooting at targets. The record did not contain additional details suggesting that this activity was connected to specific violent operations. As such, the court found no evidence that his work as a training master constituted a significant contribution to crimes. Similarly, his position within the intelligence department did not indicate membership in the inner leadership circle or that he was conferred special authority. According to the evidence, his duties consisted mainly of collecting, archiving or forwarding information to his superior. The court acknowledged that these activities might have supported the LTTE's broader objectives, especially given that they were carried out over several years. However, even considering the lower standard of proof applicable in cases involving crimes committed abroad, the evidence did not establish a sufficiently concrete link between the applicant's activities and specific reprehensible acts committed by the LTTE.


The court also rejected the SEM's reliance on the applicant's family connections and alleged ideological proximity to the LTTE as proof of involvement in violent acts. The mere fact that his brothers were high-ranking LTTE members did not demonstrate that the applicant himself had committed or contributed to crimes. The court likewise found no indication that he had attempted to minimise his role during the proceedings.


In conclusion, the Federal Administrative Court determined that the file did not establish with the necessary degree of certainty that the applicant had made a concrete and individual contribution to reprehensible acts under Article 53 of the Asylum Act. As a result, the legal basis for excluding him from asylum was not met.


As the court found that the requirement of reprehensible acts was not satisfied, it considered it unnecessary to examine in detail whether exclusion from asylum would have been disproportionate in this case. It concluded that the applicant should be granted asylum.


Country of Decision
Switzerland
Court Name
CH: Federal Administrative Court [Bundesverwaltungsgericht - Tribunal administratif fédéral - FAC]
Case Number
D-6231/2019
Date of Decision
29/11/2022
Country of Origin
Sri Lanka
Keywords
Assessment of applications
Exclusion
Individual responsibility
Aiding and abetting
Excludable acts attributed to a group or regime
Modes of individual responsibility
Refugee status/protection