An Afghan national applied for asylum on 29 August 2021. The Federal Office for Immigration and Asylum rejected his application. An appeal lodged before the Federal Administrative Court was also dismissed. The court considered that the applicant should be excluded from protection as when he was 16 years old, two days before he left his home country, he shot and killed his paternal uncle and cousin after they became violent against his mother for her refusal to enter into a forced marriage with the uncle after her husband passed away. It found that the applicant never submitted that the situation would have been life threatening, nor did this emerge following an assessment of the facts. The court considered that there was no excusable state of emergency within the meaning of Austrian law, as the uncle and cousin were unarmed. In this regard, it considered that shooting at two people could be considered a much more serious consequence than the acts of violence perpetrated by the uncle and cousin, especially considering the fatal consequences. The court thus ruled that the applicant committed a serious crime under Article 6(1)(2) of the Asylum Act 2005 and Article 1(F)(b) of the Geneva Refugee Convention, and that the crime was not political as it was committed for purely personal reasons. Finally, it considered that in the event of a return to Afghanistan, he would not be threatened with persecution from his paternal cousins, since he was the perpetrator, and blood feuds relevant to asylum would only be directed against uninvolved family members of the offender.
The applicant submitted an onward appeal on a point of law before the Supreme Administrative Court.
The court noted that Article 6(1)(2) of the Asylum Act 2005 transposes Article 12(2) of the recast Qualification Directive (QD), according to which an applicant is excluded from international protection if there are serious reasons to believe that they committed a serious non-political crime outside of the host country. The court observed that, for a crime to be considered serious, it must be predominantly regarded as a criminal offence in other legal systems. It also referred to the purposes of the exclusion grounds, which includes excluding persons who are unworthy of protection and to prevent perpetrators from evading criminal liability.
The court held that serious consequences of exclusion lead to a restrictive interpretation of the exclusion clauses, and sufficient finding of facts are necessary to assess whether the applicant's conduct falls under the exclusion grounds. The court emphasised that exclusion requires a balancing of the reprehensibility of the offence of which the asylum seeker is suspected and his protective interests (degree of the feared persecution), which requires a comprehensive clarification of the facts. The court observed that several factors must be taken into account, including mitigating reasons, reasons for exclusion of guilt and justification, while the offence must also be serious from a subjective point of view.
Based on UNHCR guidance, the court noted that the applicant must have also committed the offence with intent and knowledge for criminal liability to be established. It held that consideration must be regarded to grounds for justification and excuses in the examination of criminal responsibility, while highlighting that actions in self-defence or in defence of others or property must be both appropriate and proportionate in relation to the threat.
It found the federal court's assessment to be insufficient, as it failed to recognise the requirement to justify the application of the exclusion ground. The court noted that the federal court did not take into account all the circumstances of the event to clarify whether the conduct could be characterised as a serious non-political crime. It described the federal court's examination of an ‘exculpatory state of emergency' to be brief, and considered that a comprehensive examination of whether the applicant acted in self-defence to prevent an unlawful attack on his mother, was omitted.
It also found the federal court's assessment with regards to the threat of blood revenge to be unlawful as it lacked comprehensive reasoning. It observed that the decision lacked any country information on the subject of blood revenge, and any weighting of the applicant's submissions on the alleged persecution.
In light of the above, the Supreme Administrative Court set aside in its entirety the decision of the federal court.