An Eritrean applicant applied for international protection on 27 June 2013. The Directorate of Immigration (UDI) excluded him from international protection as it considered that he had been guilty of torture while working as a guard in a military camp in his home country, including by punishing recruits by hanging them up in a so-called ‘otto position'. In subsequent appeals, both the Immigration Appeals Board (UNE) and the Oslo District Court upheld this decision, finding serious grounds to believe that he was guilty of committing a serious non-political crime. The applicant then appealed the decision of the UNE before the Borgarting Court of Appeal
The court set out the applicable legal framework, with reference also to UNHCR guidelines on exclusion. It concluded that the applicant had not committed a serious crime that would justify exclusion from refugee status. It noted that UNE's decision did not independently justify why the applicant's actions met the threshold for a serious non-political crime but relied on the UDI's reasoning, which described his participation in military punishments during his service in Eritrea. According to the UDI, he had tied up recruits, handed them over to others for military punishment, including exposure to the sun and exercises, and on one occasion participated in punishing three individuals in the “otto position” for two hours each day over three days. The UDI assumed that these actions aligned with country information on Eritrean military punishment and torture practices. UNE, despite noting UDI's misrepresentation of the applicant's statements, held that the applicant has ‘hung up' the individuals in the ‘otto position' and maintained that his actions still constituted torture.
On appeal, the State emphasised that ‘otto' method is a painful torture method which has been used in Eritrea for generations, involving tightly tying a person's hands behind their back either while sitting, standing, or being laid on their stomach, with the aim of inflicting punishment. It argued that the 20009 report ‘Service for Life' by Human Rights Watch described it as a ‘torture method', leading to the automatic assumption by the UNE that this practice constitutes torture.
The Court of Appeal observed that the State's description of the applicant's actions, which were argued as grounds for excluding him from refugee status, had changed over time, and that while hanging someone in the “otto” position for two hours a day over three days would have been serious enough to justify exclusion, there was no basis for that accusation. The court examined whether the evidence at the appeal showed that the applicant committed torture or other serious crimes in Eritrea, relying on the asylum interview minutes from July and August 2013, which also underpinned UNE's decision. The court found the transcript to be vague and imprecise, lacking follow-up questions that would distinguish between A's own actions and the general military authority to punish recruits and that would clarify the punishments he inflicted himself, and the consequences for the recruits. While the statements indicated that he tied recruits, put them in the sun, and ordered them to roll around, including one instance of punishing three fugitives in the ‘otto' position, the court held that the use of the term ‘otto' could not automatically be interpreted as torture. The interviewer had introduced the term without explanation, and the applicant was not asked to clarify what he meant when he also used the term. Expert evidence clarified that ‘otto' primarily involves tying hands behind the back, with variations in position, but there was no evidence that the applicant's actions involved tying in a way that caused pain or combined other elements such as lying on the stomach or being hung. The court concluded that UNE's generalisation based on the term ‘otto' was “unfortunate” and inconsistent with UNHCR guidelines, which require a full assessment of the individual circumstances before excluding someone from refugee status.
The court also concluded that tying the hands behind the backs of three individuals for two hours a day over three days, even if confirmed, does not meet the threshold for a ‘serious crime' as understood under Section 31 (1)(b) of the Immigration Act, considering UNHCR guidelines which provides examples such as murder, rape, and armed robbery. Furthermore, the court considered the purpose of the exclusion clause and found that the applicant's actions did not demonstrate that he was unworthy of refugee protection, exploiting the Convention, or posing a security risk.
The court held that while the applicant participated in punishment including putting people in the sun and ordering them to roll around, in light of the low level of precision and the lack of follow up questions during the interview, it could not assume that these acts constituted a serious crime. It also noted that it had not been demonstrated that the applicant punished people of his own initiative in a manner which provided grounds for exclusion.
Thus, the court ruled that the applicant has not been guilty of a serious crime and upheld the appeal.