An application for international protection filed by a Nigerian national was rejected by the State Secretary for Justice and Security on 15 September 2022, and again on 30 May 2022. An appeal was upheld by the District Court of the Hague, seated in Roermond, on 9 April 2024. The State Secretary for Justice and Security filed an appeal against this decision before the Council of State.
The Council of State considered whether the applicant should be excluded from international protection on the ground of having committed a serious non-political crime under Article 1(F)(b) of the Geneva Convention. In this regard, the applicant was a member of a violent cult group called Eiye and participated in various violent activities over a six year period, including abusing new members during initiation rituals and seriously abusing many other individuals, as well as seriously injuring a member of a rival cult group with an axe.
The Council of State noted that in line with the 'Background Note on the Application of the Exclusion Clauses' of the UNHCR, criminal offences, involving the use of a lethal weapon, and/or serious injury to persons, and/or evidence of repeated serious criminal behaviour are example of a serious non-political crime. Although it acknowledged that not every assault reaches the threshold of seriousness to justify the application of the exclusion grounds, the applicant's conduct in this case met these international standards in light of its nature, seriousness and repetitiveness. The Council of State thus considered that the State Secretary was correct to assume the position that the serious assaults committed by the applicant, including the use of an axe, were a serious crime, falling under the scope of Article 1(F) (b) of the Geneva Convention.
Subsequently, the Council of State assessed whether the applicant knowingly committed the acts and whether he personally participated in any way, referred to as ‘knowing participation' under paragraph C2/7.10.2.4 of the Vc 2000. The Council of State upheld the position of the State Secretary that there was knowing participation, and considered that the applicant himself stated that he had committed the crime. Furthermore, in view of the seriousness of the abuse, the Council of Stat held that the applicant knew or should have known that it was serious conduct. Hereto, the Council of State noted that the applicant had acknowledged his awareness that he had committed serious criminal offences, and that it was not required for the applicant to know that the crime reached the seriousness threshold required by the exclusion provisions, asserting that someone lacking legal knowledge of the Geneva Convention can realise that abusing people with an axe was forbidden.
Consequently, the appeal was declared well founded and the Council of State the judgment of the District Court. Following this, the Council of State assessed the grounds of appeal on which the District Court has not yet given an appeal.
The applicant argued that he should be exempted from individual responsibility as he had joined the cult under duress and that he has attempted twice to leave in 2013 but was unable to due to the risk of reprisals. The Council of State declared that this ground of appeal failed. It held that although it follows from COI that forced accession occurs and that cult members who attempt to leave may face reprisals, the applicant failed to establish the plausibility in his case, as according to his statements, he had joined Eiye in the hopes of becoming more popular, gain respect and no longer have to fear anyone. The Council of State therefore considered that it does not emerge from the statements that he was forced to join the cult, not has he made it plausible that he remained a member under duress or that he tried to evade Eiye. Rather, the Council of State held that his statements demonstrated that over the years he was entrusted with more powers and responsibilities within the group.
Additionally, the Council of State assessed the risk of a violation of Article 3 of the ECHR upon return to Nigeria. The Council of State found that the fear of the applicant with regards to reprisals from Eiye, and from the family of one of his victims to not be credible, considering that the applicant remained in Nigeria for 8 months after leaving the cult without experiencing any problems in this regard. The Council of State also noted that since the applicant's departure form Nigeria, the applicant or his family had not received any message from Eiye or the family or cult of that victim, and that the applicant has also not heard from Eiye since 2016. It also referred to available country information which stated that former cult members can settle in other federal states.
Furthermore, the Council of State considered it not plausible the applicants claim that his father will force him to join the Ogboni if returned to Nigeria, highlighting that based on the applicant's statement, he did not experience any problems after 2016 following his refusal to become a member of the Ogboni and he had maintained good contact with his family since then. It also has not been evidenced that the Ogboni themselves had approached or pressured the applicant to become a member, whilst country information showed that membership of the Ogboni is in principle voluntary.
The applicant also claimed that the members of the All Progressive Congress (APC), with whom his father had problems, would kill him if he returned to Nigeria. However, the Council of State also found this claim to lack plausibility as the applicants account was contradictory and lacked credibility.
Finally, the applicant argued that the imposition of an entry ban for 10 years was disproportionate considering that the crimes were committed a long time ago and under duress, they were not crimes against humanity, and he regrets them, therefore, he argued that he did not constitute a present, genuine and sufficiently serious threat to public policy. Hereto, the Council of State noted that to assess the existence of a genuine, present and sufficiently serious threat affecting one of the fundamental interests of society, all the factual and legal information relating to the situation of the applicant in relation to the offence he has committed, such as the nature and seriousness of those offences and the time that has elapsed since they were committed must be taken into account by the State Secretary. Additionally, the results of this assessment must be indicated in the reasoning of the decision. In this case, the Council of State found that the applicant had not made in plausible that the crimes were committed under duress, nor did it follow from his statement that he took responsibility for his actions or repents of them. This ground of appeal was thus declared unfounded.