V. M. B., a national of Vietnam requested international protection in the Czech Republic. On 29 May 2024, the Ministry of the Interior rejected the application on the grounds that the applicant had committed a serious crime, specifically illicit production and other handling of psychotropic substances and poisons, as a member of an organized group, which fell under the exclusion clause of Section 15a of the Asylum Act. The applicant was convicted for this crime and sentenced to 9 years in prison, alongside with an expulsion order from the Czech Republic for a period of 5 years.
The applicant lodged an appeal against the decision of the Ministry of the Interior. The Regional Court in Hradec Králové upheld the decision and dismissed the appeal on 21 January 2025. The applicant filed a cassation complaint, arguing that his application for international protection was related to his family circumstances: his wife, who holds permanent residency in the Czech Republic, and two minor children, who are Czech nationals, reside in the country. The applicant expressed regret for committing the crime and argued that being separated from his family, especially his children, made it impossible for him to maintain a family life, which led him to seek subsidiary protection in the Czech Republic. The applicant also expressed that relocation of his family back to Vietnam was not a possibility due to the degree of integration into the Czech society. The applicant claimed that the Ministry of the Interior did not take into consideration the interests of his minor children and his family life and the international obligations of the Czech Republic under various conventions, such as the European Convention on Human Rights, which prioritize family unity. The applicant also requested, the suspension of the cassation proceedings until the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) issued a preliminary ruling, A.B. v Ministry of the Interior (Ministerstvo vnitra České republiky) (C-349/24).
SAC examined whether the judgment of the Regional Court in Hradec Králové, which had dismissed the applicant's appeal on 21 January 2025, had deviated from established case law or committed a fundamental error. The court reviewed the application of the exclusion clause under Section 15a of the Asylum Act, which disqualified individuals from subsidiary protection if they had committed serious crimes, including the illicit production and trafficking of narcotics. SAC also found that both the Ministry of the Interior and the Regional Court in Hradec Králové had adequately evaluated the seriousness of the applicant's criminal activity. In particular, SAC acknowledged that they had individually assessed the seriousness of the applicant's criminal activity relying on case law from the CJEU, Shajin Ahmed (Afghanistan) v Immigration and Asylum Office (HU, Bevándorlási És Állampolgársági Hivatal) (C-369/17) and SAC's previous judgments (6 Azs 309/2016-28, 3546/2017, 5 Azs 189/2015-127). The SAC upheld the assessment concerning a serious crime made by the Ministry of Interior which had noted that the applicant's criminal behavior was classified as particularly serious, with long-term impacts on both the Czech society and the international obligations regarding drug crimes. Therefore, SAC concluded that the exclusion clause was correctly invoked.
The court also considered the applicant's claims regarding his family situation, including the potential harm to his minor children and the impact of expulsion on his family life. SAC referenced prior case law (1 Azs 76/2021-41, 8 Azs 83/2016-62, 1 Azs 49/2020-32), confirming that such issues must be addressed in the context of international protection requests, specifically concerning subsidiary protection. SAC held that the best interests of the child should be examined in relation to the appropriateness of the administrative expulsion of the child's parent, which is a question that, by its very nature, has no place in asylum proceedings and that a person to whom an exclusion clause has been applied shall enjoy the protection of the rights guaranteed by the ECHR or, where applicable, the EU Charter in subsequent proceedings concerning expulsion or return.
Furthermore, it concluded that the Regional Court in Hradec Králové had correctly established that the restriction on the applicant's family life in the Czech Republic was proportionate in view of the interest in protecting society. With regard to the request to suspend the cassation complaint proceedings until the CJEU rules on the preliminary question referred for a preliminary ruling, it found no merit in this request since the cassation appeal concerned the decision to apply an exclusionary clause and not the rejection of subsidiary protection.
The Supreme Administrative Court dismissed the cassation complaint and upheld the judgment of the Regional Court in Hradec Králové holding that the applicant's serious criminal conviction justified exclusion from subsidiary protection, notwithstanding his personal and family circumstances.