A.B., a national of the Russian Federation of Tatar ethnicity and Muslim faith, applied for international protection in Slovakia on 27 March 2024. He claimed that he had been politically active in Russia in the context of the Tatar National Movement since 2010, and noted that he had joined E.F.G party in 2016 which was banned in Russia and considered a terrorist organization. He claimed facing persecution by the Russian authorities, including the FSB and the Ministry of the Interior. He alleged being wanted in Russia, where in case of return, he would face imprisonment of at least 20 years, as well as abuse and degrading treatment in prison. Finally, he referred to the deteriorating situation of Muslims in the Russian Federation since April 2024.
On 16 December 2024, the Ministry of the Interior (the Ministry) denied the applicant both asylum and subsidiary protection, on the grounds that E.F.G party was considered a terrorist group in Russia and in some European countries such as Germany and the United Kingdom. It also denied that the penalties he would face in Russia would be so disproportionate to warrant protection under Section 2(d) of the Asylum Act, since the penalties imposed for terrorism-related offences in Russia are comparable to those in Slovakia. Additionally, the Ministry recognized that the risk of serious harm posed by unfavourable prison conditions in Russia would normally entitle the applicant to subsidiary protection. However, the Ministry stated that his mere membership of E.F.G. party constituted incitement to commit terrorist acts, and thus the applicant was excluded from subsidiary protection under Section 13(c)(e) of the Asylum Act, since he posed a danger to society.
On 5 February 2025, the applicant challenged the decision before the Administrative Court in Bratislava. In its submissions in the appeal proceedings, the Ministry referred to the EASO Practical Guide on Exclusion for Serious Non-Political Crimes (December 2001).
In its reasoning, the Administrative Court held that the Ministry had not properly evaluated the nature of the E.F.G. party and the differing positions regarding its classification as a terrorist organization. The court found it unclear on what considerations the Ministry relied in concluding that the party is unequivocally a terrorist organization, also because it failed to identify the specific activities allegedly carried out by the applicant in support of the party. It also noted that the E.F.G. party is not listed among the terrorist organizations of the European Union in the Council Decision (CFSP) 2025/207 of 30 January 2025, and that Slovakia does not consider it a terrorist organization. The court further stated that the Ministry could not rely on Russia's designation of E.F.G. as terrorist, as Russia applies a broad and politically motivated approach to such classifications, having also banned non-violent organizations such as Jehovah's Witnesses and the company META, as reported in the EUAA COI Report on Political Opposition in the Russian Federation (December 2022). It also noted that according to public sources, since 2014 the Russian Federation has used counter-terrorism laws to persecute Tatars. The court held that Ministry's assessment was not sufficiently substantiated, and that it had erred in qualifying E.F.G. membership as a criminal offence of supporting terrorism allegedly committed by the applicant. Therefore, it did not proceed to address the contested decision's reasoning on potential penalties in Russia or their comparison with Slovak law.
Finally, the court also addressed the Ministry's decision not to grant the applicant subsidiary protection, on the basis that due to his membership of the E.F.G. party, he was a danger to society within the meaning of Section 13c(2) of the Asylum Act, and Article 17(1) of the recast Qualification Directive, which establish the exclusion grounds for subsidiary protection. The court affirmed that the reasoning of the contested decision lacked any explanation of what specific danger the applicant posed to society. The court recalled Supreme Court case law establishing the need to specify the particular activities of the applicant which may pose a danger to society to an extent that it justifies applying the above-mentioned exclusion clauses (Supreme Court of the Slovak Republic, No 1Sža/18/2010, of 30 October 2010). The court highlighted that the Ministry needed to specify which concrete activities by the applicant allegedly posed a danger to society and explain how they justified applying the exclusion clause, as such a finding must be based on objectively established facts. It also cited jurisprudence of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) according to which it must be demonstrated that the danger the applicant represents for society is present and sufficiently serious for his exclusion from international protection to be proportionate (XXX v Commissaire général aux réfugiés et aux apatrides, C-8/22). The court concluded that the Ministry's exclusion of the applicant solely based on his membership of the E.F.G. party did not fulfil these conditions, as it did not assess the specific and current nature of the possible threats he posed for society.
In conclusion, the Administrative Court in Bratislava upheld the appeal, annulled the Ministry's decision and instructed the Migration Office to reassess the applicant's eligibility for asylum and subsidiary protection, taking into account his individual circumstances, the nature of the E.F.G. party, and the situation in Russia.