D.K. applied for international protection in Poland on 11 October 2022, arguing a fear of returning to his country of origin due to political views, opposition to the government and participation in protests. On 11 April 2023, the Head of the Office for Foreigners refused to grant refugee status and subsidiary protection to the applicant but granted subsidiary protection only to the applicant's child, who was a minor. On 26 April 2023, the applicant appealed the decision for the refusal of subsidiary protection.
On 18 September 2023, the Refugee Board upheld the refusal to grant refugee status or subsidiary protection status, arguing that the applicant was not an active political oppositionist, had never conducted political activities against the authorities and that he posed a threat to the state or societal security due to pending criminal proceedings in Poland. On 27 February 2024, the Voivodship Administrative Court in Warsaw dismissed the applicant's complaint, arguing that the refusal was lawful under Article 20(1)(2)(c) of the Polish Act on Granting Protection to Foreigners. This article excludes individuals who constitute a threat to national security.
The Supreme Administrative Court (SAC) stated that it was important to determine whether there was a prerequisite to refuse to grant the applicant subsidiary protection referred to in Article 20(1)(2)(c) of the Act on granting protection to foreigners. SAC acknowledged that, according to the wording of the provision, an applicant is denied subsidiary protection if there are serious grounds to believe that the person poses a threat to the security of the state or society.
SAC found that the lower authorities and the Voivodship Administrative Court in Warsaw erroneously assumed that the facts of the case had been properly explained, resulting in an inadequate determination of the facts. SAC also held that the evidence was incorrectly assessed and that it was wrongly concluded that the applicant had left Poland and that his whereabouts were unknown.
SAC held that they misinterpreted and misapplied Article 20(1)(2)(c) because the existence of an investigation alone does not constitute a sufficient basis to conclude that the applicant poses a real and ongoing threat to state or societal security. SAC held that the fact that an applicant has committed crimes in the past was not sufficient to apply the ground for exclusion from subsidiary protection pursuant Article 20(1)(2)(c), which refers to the present and the future, not to the past. SAC held that the decisive factor is not what the applicant has done in the past and what acts he has committed, but how they translate into the current assessment of the threat to the security of the state or society in connection with his stay in the territory of Poland. According to SAC, finding that an applicant has committed crimes in the past was not sufficient to apply this ground for exclusion from subsidiary protection. Only a justified belief that the threat is still present is the proper basis for its application.
SAC annulled the appealed judgment of the Voivodship Administrative Court and the decision of the Refugee Board.