The Commissioner General for Refugees and Stateless Persons (CGRS) rejected the application for international protection, excluding the applicant from refugee and subsidiary protection. The applicant appealed to the Council for Alien Law Litigation (CALL), which on 31 March 2021 reaffirmed the CGRS's decision on the basis of his alleged involvement in war crimes under Article 8 of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (Rome Statute) committed by the armed group Mudundu 40 (M40), in which the applicant had served as a logistics commander, collecting and providing food to combatants. The alleged war crimes included murder, torture, inhuman and degrading treatment, and the enlistment of child soldiers. In the decision under appeal, the applicant was identified as being individually responsible under Article 25(c) of the Rome Statute, meaning that he aided, abetted or otherwise assisted in the commission of a crime “for the purpose of facilitating the commission of such a crime”.
The applicant filed a cassation appeal before the Council of State on 7 May 2021, based on CALL's failure to duly verify and justify his individual responsibility under domestic and international laws. He alleged an infringement of Article 149 of the Constitution, Articles 39/65 and 55/2 of the Law of 15 December 1980 on the entry, residence, establishment and removal of aliens (Belgian Aliens Law), Article 1F of the Geneva Convention and Articles 8 and 25 of the Rome Statute.
The Council of State focused on whether CALL had adequately justified the application of the exclusion clause under Article 1F(a) of the 1951 Geneva Convention and Article 55/2 of the Belgian Aliens Law, which exclude from international protection persons “with respect to whom there are serious reasons” for considering that they committed war crimes.
The applicant argued that the relevant exclusion clauses were applied too broadly, since CALL failed to demonstrate that he contributed to the alleged crimes. He claimed that it had not been established that the food he provided was used by the specific individuals who committed war crimes or that his services had a substantial effect on the actions constituting war crimes. Additionally, the nature, location and timing of the alleged crimes were also not specified. He stated that CALL had not demonstrated that he acted with the specific intent to facilitate the crimes, since it based his alleged knowledge of the crimes on a general awareness of the militia's activities. He also submitted that CALL failed to verify criminal intent, namely that he collected and provided food and money “with a view to facilitating” the crimes. Additionally, he contended that CALL violated Article 149 of the Constitution by failing to provide sufficient reasoning regarding how the legal criteria for exclusion were met, to the point where he could not understand the basis of the accusations.
The Council of State upheld the appeal. It found that while CALL cited the applicant's responsibilities within the Mudundu 40 group, including the collection of food and money for the group whilst being aware of the crimes committed by the group's members, it held that CALL nonetheless failed to provide reasons as to how the legal conditions regulating exclusion were met. In particular, the council concluded that the CALL failed to state reasons to conclude that the applicant's actions were committed ‘for the purposes of facilitating the commission' of one of these crimes resulting in a violation of the legal obligation to justify administrative decisions, as set out in Article 149 of the Constitution and Article 39/65 of the Aliens Law. Consequently, the case was referred back to CALL for reconsideration.