On 28 June 2018, a former policeman from the Kurdish Autonomous Region of Iraq requested international protection in Belgium, claiming he was subjected to mistreatment, abduction, and torture by Kurdish security forces as a result of his disobedience and perceived disloyalty. In this regard, he stated that he served 9 years in the Kurdish police, working then for a year in the elite unit of the Special Weapons and Tactics (SWAT) before becoming in 2015 one of the bodyguards of L., the director of the police in the Dohuk province. In this role, the applicant noted that L., his son, and his group were involved in trafficking of arms, with weapons captured from Daesh by the Peshmerga, as well as arbitrary arrests and excessive violence during protests. On 13 August 2016, W.H.A., a Kurdish journalist and political opponent known for supporting the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK), was found dead, with his body showing clear signs of torture. The following day, the applicant discussed the matter with colleagues, who disclosed that the journalist had allegedly been tortured and killed by L., and his associates. The next day, while attending the funeral of the journalist, the applicant inquired with Lieutenant I. about the alleged events but was instructed not to get involved. Shortly thereafter, the applicant was summoned to L.'s office, where he strongly denied the allegations and addressed him in a hostile manner. A few days later, the applicant submitted a formal request for transfer, which was denied. In September 2016, several individuals arrived at the applicant's home during the night, blindfolded and handcuffed him, and transported him to an unknown location. During the interrogation, the applicant was insulted and beaten and was released after 7 days. Following the applicant's return to work a few days after the abduction, he reported the incident and asked for further investigations, but no actions were taken.
In November 2016, the family of the murdered journalist began organising protests demanding justice. The applicant was accused by L. and his son of having leaked information that fuelled the demonstrations, of disloyalty, and of failing to fulfil his duties. On multiple occasions, Lieutenant I. allegedly ordered the applicant to repress the protests violently and beat detained protestors, orders the applicant consistently refused. These refusals led to threats from Lieutenant I., who warned the applicant of consequences for the insubordination. When the applicant once again raised the issue of his abduction with L., he was detained and held in a cell for three days, during which Lieutenant I. threatened him. In September 2017, the applicant urgently requested a transfer and threatened L.. As a result, he was arrested, detained, threatened, and tortured. Following his release, the applicant decided to flee Iraq on 17 September 2017, travelling to Türkiye, crossing the Mediterranean to Greece, and continuing the journey through several Eastern European countries. He subsequently travelled through Italy and France, arriving in Belgium on 28 June 2018, where he immediately applied for international protection. The applicant stated that since his departure, his family had been repeatedly harassed by local authorities.
The Commissioner General for Refugees and Stateless Persons (CGRS) excluded the applicant from refugee status, considering that he contributed to the commission of crimes against humanity as defined under Article 7(1)(f) of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, specifically torture. The Rome Statute defines crimes against humanity as specific acts, such as torture, committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack against a civilian population, with the perpetrator having knowledge of the attack. Accordingly, the CGRS examined the application considering the exclusion clause under Article 1F of the Geneva Convention. The CGRS recognised that torture and mistreatment of detainees and prisoners were common practices in police stations and detention centres in the Kurdish autonomous region, particularly in Dohuk. The commissioner considered the EASO Country of Origin Information Report, "Iraq: Targeting of Individuals," (March 2019), and stated that in addition to widespread arbitrary detentions, there were numerous reports of mistreatment and torture by Kurdish security forces during arrests or interrogations, including against children. The CGRS noted that the statements of the applicant confirmed that the detainees were tortured during their interrogations and that each police station and prison had a room and equipment for torturing those who refused to answer. The CGRS concluded that there was a context of a widespread or systematic attack against a civilian population, executed in line with or in pursuit of the policy of a State or organisation seeking to implement such an attack, carried out at the relevant time and locations by Kurdish authorities in northern Iraq.
The CGRS observed that, during his time in the SWAT unit, the applicant took part in the arrest of multiple individuals. Although the applicant's interviews suggested that he never personally conducted an interrogation or witnessed torture sessions, the CGRS concluded that he was aware of the events that occurred during the arrests and thus played a role in facilitating the commission of a crime as defined in Article 7(1) of the Rome Statute, specifically causing severe physical or mental harm to the detainees' health or well-being. The CGRS took into account the applicant's statements, in which he asserted that he only became fully aware of the extent of these practices after joining the SWAT and acknowledged that the acts committed were unacceptable to him. However, he also admitted that he did not attempt to stop or distance himself from these actions, alleging an inability to act due to the confidential nature of the work and his obligation to follow orders. Although the applicant claimed that he refrained from taking action due to the fear of imprisonment and fines, the CGRS acknowledged that these circumstances did not meet the restrictive criteria outlined in Article 31 of the Rome Statute for excluding criminal responsibility, such as coercion resulting from a threat of imminent death or serious, continuous, or imminent harm to oneself or others. Additionally, the CGRS found that the applicant's situation did not align with the exemptions provided under Article 33 of the Rome Statute, which relates to orders from a superior or public authority. The CGRS also highlighted that the abandonment of a position within the Kurdish police did not automatically lead to legal proceedings under the Iraqi Internal Security Forces Penal Code of 2008. Considering the above, the CGRS excluded the applicant from international protection on the grounds that there were serious reasons to believe that he had committed acts falling under Article 1F of the Geneva Convention.
The applicant appealed the decision before the Council for Alien Litigation (CALL), contesting the relevance of the reasoning in light of the specific facts of the case.
The CALL emphasised that the application of an exclusion clause in international protection cases required establishing both the commission of an act that could justify exclusion and the individual responsibility of the applicant. It stated that this approach aligned with the EASO Judicial analysis – Exclusion: Articles 12 and 17 Qualification Directive – 2nd edition 2020, and the EASO Practical Guide: Exclusion, (January 2017).
The CALL first examined whether an act that could result in exclusion had been committed. In this case, the allegations against the applicant fell under Article 1F of the Geneva Convention, under crimes against humanity, for which the assessment was to determine whether: (I) there was a widespread or systematic attack against a civilian population (as defined in Article 7 of the Rome Statute), (II) acts that could lead to exclusion have been committed, and (III) there were serious reasons to believe that the applicant bore individual responsibility.
The CALL established that the Iraqi Kurdish police systematically engaged in arbitrary arrests, forced confessions, ill-treatment, and acts of torture against civilians, including political opponents and journalists, findings that aligned with the applicant's statements. Hence, the CALL found that it could be reasonably established that the Iraqi police authorities, including in the autonomous Kurdish region, committed crimes against humanity. The CALL recognised that while information on torture and ill treatment practices did not specifically refer to the SWAT unit the applicant belonged to, it remained relevant as it concerned the general situation within the entire police force in the Iraqi Kurdistan region, including in Dohuk. Although the applicant argued that the torture mentioned was mainly directed against Daesh members, who he claimed were not considered “citizens” in principle, the CALL considered that they remained “civilians” within the meaning of Article 7 of the Rome Statute. In view of the administrative and procedural files submitted by the CGRS, the CALL believed that such acts of torture were systematically carried out by the Iraqi Kurdish police forces at the time the applicant was a member.
The CALL had to determine whether the applicant individually contributed to these crimes, evaluating three aspects: (i) material elements, (ii) mental elements, (iii) possible grounds for exemption from responsibility. Regarding the material element (actus reus and method of commission), the CALL already established that torture and crimes against humanity were committed by the Iraqi Kurdish police forces at the time the applicant was part of them. In this case, the CALL believed that there were serious grounds to think that the applicant's actions constituted a form of contribution to the acts of torture, since he participated in the arrests of individuals whom he then handed over to other law enforcement members for interrogation. It then clarified that the applicant was not reproached solely for his presence at the police station during the torture, but for his indirect involvement through the arrests he made and his knowledge of the practices occurring in the police stations. In considering the mental element (mens rea), the CALL needed to determine whether the applicant's state of mind at the time of the events could have led to individual responsibility, specifically whether the arrests, which were subsequently followed by torture, were made intentionally and with knowledge. The CALL recalled that, it was not required that the applicant intended to subject individuals to torture, but that he only intended to arrest them. Thus, the CALL established that the applicant acted with the prerequisite intent and knowledge. Finally, the CALL examined whether the applicant could claim the existence of any grounds for exemption from his individual responsibility. The CALL considered that the mitigating circumstances cited by the applicant (his young age, the context of the Kurdish society, the short duration of the events, and his opposition to torture), could not be accepted as grounds for exemption of his individual responsibility.
In addition, the CALL found that none of the applicant's statements suggested that he was subjected to duress, which is a ground for exemption from criminal responsibility under Article 32(1) of the Rome Statute. The CALL then reminded that the exclusion from refugee status is not subject to a proportionality review, contrary to what the applicant stated. Moreover, it underlined that the applicant's psychological fragility did not alter the findings of the decision regarding the serious reasons to believe he committed acts of torture. The CALL also noted that the documents submitted in support of the appeal, namely two testimonies, one from a doctor friend and the other from a person presented as a recognised refugee who had been a peshmerga, were irrelevant to the analysis of the applicant's exclusion.
The CALL upheld the exclusion of the applicant from international protection, concluding that there were serious reasons to believe that he contributed to crimes against humanity as provided under Article 1F of the Geneva Convention, and that he should be excluded from refugee status.