Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

​​

09/07/2024
BE: The Council for Alien Law Litigation confirmed the exclusion from international protection of a Congolese national on the grounds that the applicant had participated in the systematic killing of people from the Bundu Dia Kongo group and hence had committed, voluntarily and knowingly, crimes against humanity.
09/07/2024
BE: The Council for Alien Law Litigation confirmed the exclusion from international protection of a Congolese national on the grounds that the applicant had participated in the systematic killing of people from the Bundu Dia Kongo group and hence had committed, voluntarily and knowingly, crimes against humanity.

ECLI
Input Provided By
EUAA Information and Analysis Sector (IAS)
Other Source/Information
Type
Decision
Original Documents
Relevant Legislative Provisions
Recast Asylum Procedures Directive (Directive 2013/32/EU on common procedures for granting and withdrawing international protection) (recast APD) and/or APD 2005/85/CE; Recast Qualification Directive (Directive 2011/95/EU on standards for the qualification of third-country nationals or stateless persons as BIP for a uniform status for refugees or for persons eligible for subsidiary protection)(recast QD)/or QD 2004/83/EC; UN International Covenants / UN Conventions
Reference
Belgium, Council for Alien Law Litigation [Conseil du Contentieux des Étrangers - CALL], X. v Commissioner General for Refugees and Stateless Persons (le Commissaire Général aux Réfugiés et aux Apatrides; de Commissaris-generaal voor de vluchtelingen en de staatlozen; CGRS; CGRA; CGVS), No 309 460, 09 July 2024. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.
Permanent link to the case
https://caselaw.euaa.europa.eu/pages/viewcaselaw.aspx?CaseLawID=4938
Case history
Other information
Abstract

The applicant is a Congolese national who resided in Kinshasha. He requested international protection in Belgium on 28 March 2022. He claimed to have worked as a police officer in the Rapid Intervention Police (PIR) and the National Intervention Legion (LNI) both integrated into the Congolese National Police (PNC). In support of his application, he argued that he feared the Congolese authorities as he had refused to obey certain orders. For this reason, the applicant claimed that he was wanted by the National Intelligence Agency.


The Commissioner General for Refugees and Stateless Persons (CGRS) rejected the application for international protection on 25 February 2022, on the grounds that there were serious motives to believe that the applicant had been guilty of crimes against humanity within the meaning of Article 7 of the 1998 Rome Statute and Article 1(f)(a) of the Refugee Convention.


The CGRS observed that it was apparent from the information submitted that the PNC, and in particular the PIR and the LNI, were guilty of serious human rights violations during the years in which the applicant was employed, such as acts of torture, arbitrary detention, enforced disappearances and killings of civilians. Moreover, the CGRS considered that the applicant's individual liability had been clearly established, as he had actively taken part in various brutal repressions against the Congolese civilian population and that he had been fully aware of the illegality of his acts, without having tried to oppose those actions or leave his post. 


The applicant filed an appeal before the Belgian Council for Alien Law Litigation (CALL). The applicant disputed, in essence, the relevance of the statement of reasons for the contested decision in the light of the specific factual circumstances of the present case. He claimed that he had acted against his will and out of fear of being arrested or killed by the Congolese authorities, and that it had not been possible for him to change his unit or resign from his duties. Consequently, he requested to be recognised as a refugee or to be granted subsidiary protection. In the alternative, he sought the annulment of the contested decision.


CALL confirmed the decision of the CGRS and excluded the applicant from refugee and subsidiary protection. 


CALL recalled that an exclusion clause in matters of international protection required, first, a determination that an act capable of exclusion has been committed and, second, that there are serious reasons to believe that the applicant is individually liable in that regard. In this sense, the CALL referenced the EUAA publications, namely the Judicial analysis, Exclusion: Articles 12 and 17 Qualification Directive, 2nd edition, 2020 and the EASO Practical Guide: Exclusion, January 2017.


Regarding the existence of an act liable to lead to exclusion, the defendant claimed that the applicant had committed acts corresponding to crimes against humanity. To determine if there had been a crime against humanity, the CALL examined two points: whether there had been a generalised or systematic attack against a civilian population in the pursuit of the policy of a State and whether acts capable of exclusion had been committed in that context. 


Regarding the first point, the CALL based its reasoning on the case law of the International Criminal Court, as well as on the facts provided by a Human Rights Watch Report and a United Nations Special Report. In the light of those considerations, the Council considered that it was reasonably established that the PNC, including the PIR and the ‘cobra' battalion to which the applicant belonged, were guilty, in the province of Lower Congo and during at least the period during which the applicant was in office there, of a widespread or systematic attack against a civilian population in pursuit of the policy of a State, within the meaning of Article 7 of the Rome Statute.


Once the CALL established the existence of a systemic attack against a civilian population, it then examined if there had been acts committed that qualified as crimes against humanity and whether there was a link between those acts and the systemic attack. In the present case, the Council observed that it was sufficiently clear from the information contained in the administrative file that, in February and March 2008, the PIR to which the applicant belonged at that time, was guilty of arbitrary executions, torture, inhuman and degrading treatment, arbitrary arrests, unlawful detentions, looting, destruction of private property and sexual violence. It also considered that the generalised and systematic nature of those abuses reflected the link with the generalised or systematic attack against a civilian population, specifically the BDK political and religious movement, which the Congolese authorities aimed to eradicate.


The Council then went on to examine the applicant's individual responsibility for the abovementioned crimes. To do so it analysed three aspects: the material components, the moral element and any grounds for exemption from liability.


As to the material elements, the Council examined the applicant's actual involvement in the acts. It observed that the applicant had had a long career in the PNC, eventually obtaining the rank of second lieutenant, and that he had admitted to carrying out operations aimed at killing members of BDK and setting fire to BDK buildings. The applicant also admitted that he had personally used an assault rifle to kill people en masse, including unarmed people. The CALL therefore concluded that there were serious reasons to believe that the applicant was personally guilty of abuses in Lower Congo during 2009, directly killing armed or unarmed civilians and issuing orders to kill civilians, burn buildings, commit enforced disappearances and, ultimately, persecute a well-identified group. 


As to the moral element, the CALL analysed whether the applicant's state of mind at the time of the facts could give rise to his individual responsibility. In this sense, the CALL began by referring to EUAA 's Judicial analysis, Exclusion: Articles 12 and 17 Qualification Directive, which explained that criminal intent is composed of two elements, the actual knowledge (scis) and the will (volens) of the implementation of the act in each of its constituent elements. In the present case, the CALL observed that the voluntary nature of the applicant's engagement within the PIR, the nature of the duties he performed and the long duration of his duties in the Lower Congo region sufficiently demonstrated that the applicant had actual knowledge of the crimes he committed and that he had the will to commit them.


Once the CALL had established that the applicant participated, voluntarily and knowingly, in the commission of a crime against humanity, it then examined whether there were grounds for exempting him from individual liability. In this sense, the applicant claimed that he had acted against his will because he risked being killed or arrested if he deserted or refused to obey. On the other hand, the defendant considered that it was not apparent from the applicant's statements that he acted under coercion as he had never attempted to avoid his obligations and that self-defence could not be invoked either, in view of the brutality and scale of the abuses committed which were not proportionate to the danger faced by the applicant. For its part, the Council highlighted the applicant's long and evolving involvement in the PIR and his function within the chain of command. It also observed that the context described by the applicant did not make it seem impossible for him to evade his obligations, or the orders given. Consequently, it fully agreed with the reasoning of the contested decision, which rejected possible grounds for exemption. 


Finally, regarding the arguments put forward in the application, relating to the fact that the decision excluding the applicant from refugee status and subsidiary protection status did not consider the impossibility for the applicant to return to the DRC because of a fear of persecution, the CALL considered that they did not allow for another assessment. The Council pointed out that Articles 55/2 and 55/4 of the Law of 15 December 1980 did not require verification of the conditions for the inclusion of international protection before concluding that the applicant is excluded from the benefit of that protection and that those factors, which, moreover, are unsubstantiated, relate exclusively to a possible fear of persecution on the part of the applicant.


The CALL concluded that there were reasons to believe that the applicant has committed and participated in crimes against humanity within the meaning of Article 1(F)(a) of the Geneva Convention and that he should be excluded from refugee status and from subsidiary protection. 


Country of Decision
Belgium
Court Name
BE: Council for Alien Law Litigation [Conseil du Contentieux des Étrangers - CALL]
Case Number
No 309 460
Date of Decision
09/07/2024
Country of Origin
Democratic Republic of the Congo
Keywords
Appeal / Second instance determination
Assessment of applications
Country of Origin Information (COI)
EUAA Materials
EUAA Judicial Analysis / EUAA Professional Development Series
EUAA Other Materials
Exclusion
Crimes against humanity
Grounds negating individual responsibility
Duress
Superior orders
Individual responsibility
Direct commission of an excludable act
Modes of individual responsibility
State of mind
Refugee status/protection
Military service / Conscientious objection / Desertion / Draft evasion / Forced conscription