An Eritrean national requested international protection in Belgium on 29 October 2021. On 14 November 2023, the CGRS decided to exclude the applicant from international protection. The applicant appealed the decision on 20 December 2023. Among other arguments regarding the substance of his claim, the applicant argued that there had not been an adequate proportionality test in the contested decision about his private and family life. He further expressed fear upon return to experience treatment contrary to Article 3 of the ECHR and that the determining authority had abstained from issuing a return decision.
The CALL upheld the decision of the determining authority and excluded the applicant from international protection.
Referring to the relevant legal framework and principles in exclusion cases, the CALL stated that:
- Articles 55/2 and 55/4 of the Aliens Act must be interpreted and applied restrictively and with the utmost care, only in exceptional situations.
- The burden of proof rests solely on the applicant in view of the exceptional nature of those exclusion clauses and the general principle of law that it is for the person wishing to rely on a fact to prove it.
- An applicant does not need to have been convicted of a criminal offense to apply grounds of exclusion, nor is it required that the criminal standard of proof, namely ‘beyond all reasonable doubt' is met. The standard of proof in asylum cases is ‘serious reasons to believe' that the applicant is responsible for crimes or acts contained in Article 1F of the Refugee Convention.
- Individual responsibility for a crime against humanity must be established. Namely, it must be established that the applicant was specifically involved in a crime against humanity either as a physical perpetrator or because he has incited or otherwise participated in such a crime.
- It must be established that the applicant committed the criminal acts intentionally, knowingly and willingly (mens rea).
In substantiating this, the court referred to the CJEU judgment in Germany v B and D of 9 November 2010 and EASO Judicial Analysis: Exclusion (2020).
The court concluded that the applicant played an active role in the implementation of essential aspects of the National Service in Eritrea and that he at least facilitated crimes against humanity, in particular slavery, torture, and imprisonment, and was aware of the consequences that this would have for the conscripts in question. In this respect, the CALL held that the distinction between the military and civilian components within the National Service is irrelevant. Furthermore, the court held that as the leader of the military Ganta unit, the applicant made a substantial contribution to those crimes, at the same time aiding in preserving the system of the National Service in Eritrea. Thus, it can be established that the applicant acted with the prerequisite intent and knowledge. In this respect, the court highlighted that leaving aside the credibility of his statements on the civil nature of his duties, the applicant did not dispute that he had certain responsibilities for a group of 50 soldiers and was also in a position of power. Equally, it could be reasonably assumed that the applicant had a certain reputation as a former combatant of the War of independence.
To reach these conclusions, the CALL evaluated the statements of the applicant, the reasons and analysis provided by the determining authority and the available and most updated country of origin information. Specifically, the UN Human Rights Council Reports of the detailed findings of the Commission of Inquiry on Human Rights in Eritrea, 5 and 8 June 2015, the EASO COI Report Eritrea, Country Focus May 2015, EASO, Eritrea: National Service, exit and return, September 2019, Amnesty International Eritrea 20 years of independence but still not freedom 2013.
The CALL concluded the applicant should be excluded from refugee status and subsidiary protection.
With regards to the arguments of the applicant regarding return, the CALL highlighted that the contested decision, as such, does not constitute an expulsion measure.
Lastly, the CALL noted that the fact that the applicant's wife and children were recognised refugee status does not in any way oblige the determining authority to carry out a proportionality test about the applicant's private and family life when she examines and decides to apply exclusion clauses about the applicant.