Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

​​

16/04/2024
BE: The CALL upheld the decision of the CGRS to exclude a Syrian applicant from international protection due to his contribution to the commission of crimes against humanity whilst serving in the Syrian military.
16/04/2024
BE: The CALL upheld the decision of the CGRS to exclude a Syrian applicant from international protection due to his contribution to the commission of crimes against humanity whilst serving in the Syrian military.

ECLI
Input Provided By
EUAA Courts and Tribunals Network
Other Source/Information
Type
Judgment
Original Documents
Relevant Legislative Provisions
UN International Covenants / UN Conventions
Reference
Belgium, Council for Alien Law Litigation [Conseil du Contentieux des Étrangers - CALL], X v Commissioner General for Refugees and Stateless Persons (le Commissaire Général aux Réfugiés et aux Apatrides; de Commissaris-generaal voor de vluchtelingen en de staatlozen; CGRS; CGRA; CGVS), No 304 947, 16 April 2024. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.
Permanent link to the case
https://caselaw.euaa.europa.eu/pages/viewcaselaw.aspx?CaseLawID=4774
Case history
Other information
Abstract

The applicant is a Syrian national. He submitted an application for asylum on 13 August 2019. On 23 May 2022, the Commissioner General for Refugees and Stateless Persons (CGRS) issued a decision excluding the applicant from international protection for contributing to the commission of crimes against humanity whilst performing his military service. An appeal was lodged before the Council for Alien Law Litigation.


According to the summary provided by the EUAA Courts and Tribunals network:


“The [CGRS] excludes the applicant from international protection on the grounds that there are serious reasons to believe that he contributed to the commission of crimes against humanity within the meaning of Article 1, section F, a, of the Geneva Convention and Articles 55/2 and 55/4, § 1, of the Law of 15 December 1980.


It concludes that there are serious reasons to believe that by contributing to the arrest of persons at a Syrian army checkpoint, the applicant was complicit in the murders and ill-treatment that followed these arrests. It considers that the applicant has not provided any sufficient evidence to exonerate him from his responsibility. With regard to the classification of crimes against humanity, the Council recalls that this requires determining whether there is a widespread or systematic attack against a civilian population, whether acts capable of exclusion have been committed and whether there are serious reasons to believe that the applicant bears individual responsibility in this regard.


In the present case, the Council, relying in particular on the case-law of the International Criminal Court, considers that it is reasonably established that the Syrian security forces, including the army and the political security, were guilty of crimes against humanity in the context of the repression of demonstrators opposed to the regime in power which took place in the province of Daraa in April 2011, before spreading throughout the country. The Council considers that it is considered established that killings and torture were being carried out on a widespread basis in the city of Daraa as early as April 2011.


As to the individual responsibility of the applicant, the Council considers that there are substantial reasons to believe that the applicant's actions constituted a form of contribution (“residual complicity”) to the killings and torture within the meaning of article 25.3. d, ii, of the Rome Statute and the relevant case law of the International Criminal Court.


As to the element of intent, the Council notes, with regard to the particular mode of participation retained, that it applies to the applicant's conduct which constitutes his contribution (i.e., in this case, at the very least, the protection of individuals carrying out checks and arrests of persons at a checkpoint) and not to the criminal act to which he contributed (in this case, the killings and torture of the detainees).


The Council considers that there are serious reasons to believe that the applicant intended to participate in the checkpoint checks by ensuring the safety of both “those who were searching, such as lieutenants and warrant officers” and the intelligence officers of the political security who were there, that he was aware that they were contributing to the murders and acts of torture committed by the Syrian security forces (including the army and political security) and that he was aware of the intention of the members of the Syrian security forces to commit murders and acts of torture.


Finally, the Council considers that the applicant cannot rely on “the order of the hierarchical superior” as a ground for exoneration since the orders received were manifestly unlawful. Nor can the applicant rely on the defence of duress as a ground for exemption from individual responsibility, since the condition of the existence of an imminent threat of death or of serious, continuing or imminent harm to his own physical integrity or that of others is lacking. The applicant's alleged desertion is not credible and is therefore not considered to be established.


The Council notes that the applicant has not usefully raised any grounds for exemption from individual responsibility in terms of serious reasons for believing that he participated in crimes against humanity.


The Council concludes that the applicant should be excluded from international protection.”


 


Country of Decision
Belgium
Court Name
BE: Council for Alien Law Litigation [Conseil du Contentieux des Étrangers - CALL]
Case Number
No 304 947
Date of Decision
16/04/2024
Country of Origin
Syria
Keywords
Exclusion
Crimes against humanity
Grounds negating individual responsibility
Superior orders
Individual responsibility
Joint criminal enterprise
Modes of individual responsibility
State of mind
Refugee status/protection
Military service / Conscientious objection / Desertion / Draft evasion / Forced conscription
Torture or inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment