An Eritrean national applied for asylum in Sweden in January 2022, claiming that by speaking out against the regime and leaving his post at an Eritrean mission abroad, he risked being perceived as critical of the regime and subjected to treatment for which asylum should be provided.
His application was rejected in June 2023 by the Migration Agency, and due to temporary obstacles to enforcement of his return, he was provided with a one year temporary residence and work permit.
The applicant appealed against this decision, which was dismissed by the Migration Court. The judgment held that due to the duties that Mr A had during his 20 years of employment in a high position at an Eritrean embassy abroad, it must be considered that he participated in acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations (UN), and also held that he was not entitled to residence.
Mr A appealed against this judgment arguing that as staff of the Embassy he had to collect a diaspora tax and he had no choice about this. He further argued that it was permissible under international law for a state to tax its citizens residing abroad and this tax was introduced in order to rebuild the country after the war of independence. He also added that there was no use of threats or violence when collecting this tax and that a formal UN Security Council resolution was only in force from the end of 2011 to the end of 2018.
The Migration Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal.
The court noted that in order to decide whether the applicant should be excluded from refugee protection, it was important to determine whether the collection of diaspora tax by the Eritrean State from Eritreans living abroad may constitute an act contrary to the purposes and principles of the UN.
The court highlighted that the grounds for exclusion should be applied restrictively and that the ground concerning acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the UN is a broad ground, so an additional degree of caution should be exercised when considering whether someone should be excluded from being a refugee on this ground.
The court also noted that the purposes and principles of the UN are set out in the Preamble to the UN Charter and in Articles 1 and 2 of the Charter, which provide the framework for international cooperation and regulate the core functions of the UN to maintain international peace and security, develop friendly relations among States and achieve international cooperation.
The court noted that this ground for exclusion is intended to cover acts that attack the very basis of the international community's cooperation and thus such acts must also have an international dimension. The court held that, to apply this ground in an individual case, there must be evidence that shows with weight that an act is contrary to the purposes and principles of the UN or that the individual has been guilty of serious and repeated violations of human rights.
The court observed that the UN Security Council's resolution concerning the diaspora tax, which was in force from 5 December 2011 to 14 November 2018, clearly supported the view that the Eritrean State used illegal means in the collection of the diaspora tax and obliged Member States to act against those guilty of such acts.
Against this background, the Migration Court of Appeal considered that the evidence showed with weight that Eritrea's collection of diaspora tax from Eritreans living abroad using extortion, threats of violence, fraud and other illegal means constituted such an act that was contrary to the purposes and principles of the UN.
The court then turned to the individual assessment of the case and specifically to whether the applicant can be held liable for such acts, his role in the commission of the acts, his position in relation to the State, the degree of knowledge that he had of the acts and any pressure to which he was subjected.
The court held that country information showed that the Eritrean missions abroad had a central role in the illegal collection and during his 19 years of service in a high position at an Eritrean mission abroad, Mr A had a central role in the collection of diaspora tax, while the payment of the tax was a requirement for Eritreans to have access to consular services.
The court noted that there was no evidence that Mr A had used violence, threats of violence or fraud within his assignment, but the relevant country information showed that such methods as extortion were common at Eritrean missions.
The Migration Court of Appeal considered that Mr A, by reserving the right to consular services with the payment of the diaspora tax and the submission of a letter of repentance, had actively contributed to collecting the tax from Eritreans living abroad on behalf of the Eritrean State. It also added that his activities were related to international cooperation, so the documents had an international dimension. Since for 7 years he had worked at the Embassy while the UN resolution was in force, the court considered that the annulment of the UN Resolution did not lead to a different assessment, especially considering that the resolution was not cancelled because the information on unlawful recovery was incorrect or because the violations at Eritrean missions ceased.
The court further added that there was no evidence that Mr A tried to limit the damage or ensure that illegal methods were not used in the collection of the diaspora tax, or that he tried to change his duties or leave his post, but it was only when he was called home to Eritrea that he chose to leave his employment.
On the applicant's argument that he risked the death penalty if he refused orders or had not carried out his duties, the court held that there was no evidence that there would have been an imminent threat to his life or danger of serious bodily harm for this reason
The court concluded that the applicant had been involved in acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the UN and that he was individually responsible for these acts and was thus to be excluded from asylum.
The Migration Court of Appeal also found that Mr A risked inhuman treatment or punishment if he returned to Eritrea, which constitutes an absolute obstacle to enforcement and left it to the Migration Agency to take the necessary measures.