Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

​​

06/06/2024
NO: The Court of Appeal of Borgarting ruled that a Syrian applicant's participation in an armed rebel force against the Assad regime did not amount to serious non-political crimes and that the requirements for exclusion from refugee status had not been met.
06/06/2024
NO: The Court of Appeal of Borgarting ruled that a Syrian applicant's participation in an armed rebel force against the Assad regime did not amount to serious non-political crimes and that the requirements for exclusion from refugee status had not been met.

ECLI
Input Provided By
EUAA Information and Analysis Sector (IAS)
Other Source/Information
Type
Judgment
Original Documents
Relevant Legislative Provisions
National law only (in case there is no reference to EU law/ECHR); UN International Covenants / UN Conventions
Reference
Norway, Court of Appeal [Lagmannsrettane], Immigration Appeals Board (Utlendingsnemnda‚ UNE) v A., LB-2024-5105, 06 June 2024. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.
Permanent link to the case
https://caselaw.euaa.europa.eu/pages/viewcaselaw.aspx?CaseLawID=4372
Case history
Other information
Abstract

The applicant, A, a Syrian national applied for international protection in Norway on 31 October 2014. On 10 May 2017, the Norwegian Directorate of Immigration (UDI) granted the applicant a temporary residence permit in accordance with Section 74 of the first paragraph of the Immigration Act. The UDI rejected the application for asylum as it determined that, in accordance with Section 31 first paragraph letter b of the Immigration Act, there were serious grounds to believe the applicant had committed serious non-political crimes outside of Norway's borders. The UDI determined that the applicant was likely to have committed attempted murder since he was a member of a rebel group in Syria, the brigade militia, and had engaged in fighting and fired weapons. The applicant was however protected from being deported to Syria under Section 73 of the Immigration Act.


The applicant filed an appeal and the Immigration Appeals Board (UNE) determined that the decision to exclude the applicant from refugee status was lawful as he had committed a serious non-political crime. The applicant then appealed the decision to the Oslo District Court, which ruled on 10 November 2023 that the UNE's decision was invalid and held the state liable for compensation for the applicant's losses as a result of the unlawful decision. 


The state filed an appeal against the decision before the Borgarting Court of Appeal, which dismissed the appeal as unfounded on 6 June 2024. The court noted that the main question in this case, that of whether an asylum applicant committed a serious non-political crime, must be assessed according to international legal norms, based in particular on the Refugee convention and guidelines from UNHCR. It further added that the word "serious" takes on an independent meaning and that there is no doubt that complicity in murder and attempted murder are serious crimes in the sense of the Refugee Convention and according to UNHCR's Background Note on the Application of the Exclusion Clauses: Article 1F of the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees, section 40.


When assessing whether A's actions as a member of the brigade militia, namely taking part in fighting and firing his weapon, should be considered a "serious non-political crime", the Court of Appeal split into a majority and a minority. 


The majority concluded that the condition that A must have been guilty of a "serious non-political crime" was not met and that the applicant's participation in armed rebel forces with the aim of overthrowing the Assad regime in Syria did not amount to a serious non-political crime, even if it was assumed that attempted murder and complicity to murder had occurred during the fighting.


The majority found a clear connection between the applicant's combat actions and a political motivation to topple the regime. It was not found that the applicant or the group had committed torture, executions, or other activities that could be considered war crimes or violations of humanitarian law. It was further not determined that the applicant or the group subjected civilians to acts of terrorism or treatment that violated humanitarian law. It was noted that although civilians may have been exposed to violations, particularly when conflict occurred in cities, this was mostly due to government attacks. In addition, it is known that the government retaliated with large military forces targeting rebel-held areas, with little regard for the local population. According to the majority, this suggested that the applicant may be eligible for amnesty under Protocol II for his membership in the brigade militia.


The majority further determined that the international law rule on the most comprehensive amnesty for participants in non-international armed conflicts can be transposed in the assessment under section 31 first paragraph letter b of the Immigration Act, namely to whether a person should be excluded from asylum because they have been guilty of a serious non-political crime.


The majority held that granting asylum to combatants from a non-international armed conflict, who now have a well-founded fear of serious persecution in their home country, and who are covered by the intended scope of amnesty in Protocol II, would not be contrary to the considerations underlying the rules on exclusion from asylum.


The majority noted that, in that situation, the prerequisite is that the belligerent followed humanitarian law throughout the conflict, so that the actions would have gone unpunished if they had occurred in an international armed conflict.


The majority also highlighted that the rule on amnesty would indicate that the circumstances and methods used in the battle do not particularly call for exclusion from asylum as per UNHCR's background note. Furthermore, the majority noted that a crucial component in the proportionality assessment is that humanitarian law had been followed, and that the asylum seeker should be awarded amnesty under international law for the acts he had committed.


Following an overall assessment, the majority of the Court of Appeal determined that there was no reasons to assume the applicant had committed serious non-political crimes. The conditions for exclusion from asylum had not been met and therefore the UNE's ruling was unlawful.


The minority of the court concluded that there was serious reason to assume that A was guilty of serious non-political crimes in Syria and that he should be excluded from international protection. The minority noted that A's purpose for participating in the militia was not only political, but that an important reason for his participation was that it was expected in society that someone from each family should participate. The minority thus considered that A's political motive for participating was not strong and that it was somewhat unclear what his political motivation was more specifically. The minority also noted that the crimes of complicity in murder and attempted murder are very serious crimes which affected civilians and can thus be considered disproportionate compared to A's political motive.


Country of Decision
Norway
Court Name
NO: Court of Appeal [Lagmannsrettane]
Case Number
LB-2024-5105
Date of Decision
06/06/2024
Country of Origin
Syria
Keywords
Assessment of applications
Exclusion
Serious (non-political) crime
Commission of a serious non-political crime outside the country of refuge prior to admission as a refugee