An asylum seeker from Syria, who initially met the requirements for recognition as a refugee in section 28 subsection 1 of the Immigration Act, was excluded from refugee status under Section 31 first paragraph letter b. The exclusion was based on the fact that he was a conscript soldier in Syria in the spring of 2011, he had been ordered to participate in house searches where opposition figures were arrested and handed over to the security forces.
The applicant challenged the Immigration Appeals Board's decision to the Oslo District Court, which ruled in favour of the Board. The applicant then filed an appeal with the Court of Appeal, which upheld the applicant's appeal in A. v Immigration Board on 10 January 2023. The state appealed the decision to the Supreme Court in Applicant v Immigration Appeals Board (Utlendingsnemnda‚ UNE) on 12 December 2023.
The Supreme Court, like the Court of Appeal, found that the question of whether Section 31 first paragraph letter b of the Immigration Act, see Article 1F (b) of the Refugee Convention has been violated, must be assessed in accordance with international standards, including the Refugee Convention and guidelines of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, and not the law of the country of refuge. Reference was made to the wording and considerations of purpose. The Supreme Court further concluded, unlike the Court of Appeal, that the relevant participation in the arrest and surrender of persons who risked being subjected to torture and homicide was objectively to be regarded as complicity under Article 1F (b) of the Refugee Convention. It was not a condition that the act of complicity had resulted in a difference in the main act, as the Court of Appeal had assumed. The judgment of the Court of Appeal thus was set aside and the case sent back to the Court of Appeal for re-examination.
The Supreme Court ruled that when re-examining the case, the Court of Appeal must consider additional factors in determining whether there are grounds for exclusion, such as A's subjective guilt at the time of the actions and the significance of the threats he was exposed to, and other relevant circumstances.
A new appeal hearing was held before the Court of Appeal on 21 and 22 of March 2024. The Court of Appeal determined that the requirement for subjective guilt according to Section 31 first paragraph letter b of the Immigration Act was fulfilled as there was no doubt in the courts opinion that the applicant knew or had knowledge of the consequences of his actions, which according to the Supreme Court's decision, was complicit in serious non-political crimes before he was admitted in Norway.
In considering the threat and coercive circumstances, the Court of Appeal determined that desertion would pose a serious risk to the applicant; however, the Court of Appeal found, under considerable duress, that the choice was not based on "concerned necessarily and reasonably avoiding a threat of imminent death".
With regards to proportionality, the court noted that the Qualification Directive does not apply in Norway, but the EU Courts understanding of the exclusionary right is relevant in the interpretation of Section 31 first paragraph letter b of the Immigration Act. The Court noted that in Norway and the EU, even if the applicant is excluded from refugee status, he or she is protected from deportation under Section 74 of the Immigration Act, and that it cannot normally be a condition that a separate proportionality assessment be carried out, implying that an overall proportionality assessment could not be made in the decision.
The Could of Appeal ruled in favour of the state and dismissed the applicant's appeal. The Court of Appeal, under considerable doubt, determined that the applicant did not act under duress during the entire period, hence the exclusion provision applied. The uncertainty was tied to a three-day leave period during which the applicant may have deserted. For the remainder of the service, the Court of Appeal determined that he was in such danger that the exclusion clause did not apply.