Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

​​

21/01/2022
DE: The Regional Administrative Court of Baden-Württemberg dismissed an appeal to withdraw subsidiary protection and, after citing the CJEU Shajin Ahmed judgment (C-369/17), it held that in order to withdraw subsidiary protection based on Article 17(1)(d) of the recast Qualification Directive, there must always be a concrete risk and an individual consideration and assessment of the risks posed by the third country national.
21/01/2022
DE: The Regional Administrative Court of Baden-Württemberg dismissed an appeal to withdraw subsidiary protection and, after citing the CJEU Shajin Ahmed judgment (C-369/17), it held that in order to withdraw subsidiary protection based on Article 17(1)(d) of the recast Qualification Directive, there must always be a concrete risk and an individual consideration and assessment of the risks posed by the third country national.

ECLI
DE:VGHBW:2022:0121.A4S108.22.00
Input Provided By
EUAA Queries
Other Source/Information
Type
Decision
Original Documents
Relevant Legislative Provisions
Recast Qualification Directive (Directive 2011/95/EU on standards for the qualification of third-country nationals or stateless persons as BIP for a uniform status for refugees or for persons eligible for subsidiary protection)(recast QD)/or QD 2004/83/EC
Reference
Germany, Regional Administrative Court [Verwaltungsgericht], Applicant v Federal Office for Migration and Refugees (Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge‚ BAMF), A 4 S 108/22, DE:VGHBW:2022:0121.A4S108.22.00, 21 January 2022. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.
Permanent link to the case
https://caselaw.euaa.europa.eu/pages/viewcaselaw.aspx?CaseLawID=4243
Case history
Other information

Case law cited in the decision:

European Union, Court of Justice of the European Union [CJEU], Shajin Ahmed v Immigration and Asylum Office (HU, Bevándorlási És Állampolgársági Hivatal), C-369/17, ECLI:EU:C:2018:713, 13 September 2018.

EUAA Guidance cited in the decision:

EASO, Judicial Analysis on Exclusion: Articles 12 and 17 Qualification Directive: Second edition, February 2020.

Abstract

A Syrian national was granted subsidiary protection in 2017. Following a final conviction to a prison sentence of 3 years for causing dangerous bodily harm in 2018, subsidiary protection status was withdrawn in 2020 on the grounds of posing a danger to the general public. The Federal Office for Migration and Asylum stated that the offence committed showed that he had a complete lack of understanding for the freedom of action and self-determination of other people. The applicant appealed this decision to the Administrative Court, which revoked it, as it found that he did not pose a concrete and current danger to the general public with regard to future violations of legal interests within the meaning of section 4 (2) sentence 1 no. 4 Asylum Act (Asylgesetz). During the oral hearing, he credibly stated that he had never previously committed a criminal offence and that the incident in 2018 was a singular relational act.


The Federal Office applied for leave to appeal, which was dismissed by the Regional Administrative Court of Baden-Württemberg. The court explained in its decision the requirements for the danger. The court noted that according to the case law of the CJEU, the grounds for exclusion from subsidiary protection status are based on the regulations applicable to refugees, they are comparable in substance and are therefore to be interpreted in a comparable manner (CJEU, Judgment of Shajin Ahmed (Afghanistan) v Immigration and Asylum Office 13 September 2018, C-369/17 par. 43 et seq.). This meant that the "danger to the community or the security of the Federal Republic of Germany" on a systematic interpretation, must, like the other grounds for exclusion, also refer to expected criminal offences of "certain weight". Therefore, the court noted that the case law throughout Europe, usually confirms the exclusion ground of "danger to the community or to the security of the Member State" in the case of expected offences in connection with terrorism, homicide, drug trafficking or arms trafficking.  


The court also recalled the relevant interpretation requirements of the CJEU regarding Article 17 (1) lit. b of the recast Qualification Directive, that ruled that a currently existing, particularly serious danger is always required in the specific individual case for exclusion from subsidiary protection. It was noted that it is not the past misconduct that is primarily relevant, but the future danger. Thus, a risk prognosis must be made as in the case of expulsion and the sole existence of an "abstract" or "general" danger which can hardly be assessed in the case of an individual cannot suffice for an exclusion of subsidiary protection. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed.


Country of Decision
Germany
Court Name
DE: Regional Administrative Court [Verwaltungsgericht]
Case Number
A 4 S 108/22
Date of Decision
21/01/2022
Country of Origin
Syria
Keywords
EUAA Materials
EUAA Judicial Analysis / EUAA Professional Development Series
Exclusion
Serious (non-political) crime
Convicted for a serious crime after arrival (subsidiary protection)
Subsidiary protection
Withdrawal/End/Revocation/Renewal of protection