The case concerned whether subsidiary protection could have not been granted due to exclusion clause because the applicant was suspected to have committed a serious crime, as provided in Section 88, par. 2, clause 2 of the Aliens Act. The applicant had been caught in possession of a very dangerous narcotic, i.e. 300 ecstasy tablets, and he was suspected of the intention to sell half of those tablets on, as well as to smuggling of persons without legal residence rights into the Schengen states. Also, the applicant was suspected of the possibility of smuggling amphetamine.
In the smuggling of foreigners, the applicant had acted as part of an internationally operating group, the aim of which was to enable the travel and accommodation of persons without the necessary right of residence in the Schengen states. His role was not found to be particularly significant and to have participated in transporting at least 11 persons within the Schengen area. Neither the applicant nor his accomplices had been investigated in connection with the crimes, which directly affected the safety, health or personal integrity of another person.
Also, the ecstasy tablets possessed by the applicant and intended to be sold had been confiscated, and the smuggling of amphetamine had remained at the planning stage, so the narcotics had not ended up being distributed in either crime. Also, it was established that the applicant's activities had not been particularly of large-scale or produced large financial benefits.
The Administrative Court stated that when assessing the severity of an act in terms of Section 88, Subsection 2, Clause 2 of the Aliens Act, the nature of the criminal act and other circumstances must be taken into account. Serious crimes against the safety, health and personal integrity of another person must be considered a serious crime as referred to in the law and in some situations, the danger to public order and security caused by the suspected crime can also be important in the overall consideration.
The Administrative Court mentioned that drug crime poses a serious threat to citizens' health, safety and quality of life, as well as to the economy, stability and security of the state. However, in the present case, the Administrative Court made an assessment of the quality and the circumstances of the commission of the crimes and ruled that these crimes should not be considered serious crimes as referred to in section 88, subsection 2, point 2 of the Aliens Act, either individually or as a whole, taking into account their dangerousness. The court took into account the amount of narcotics the applicant possessed and intended to distribute and the fact that the narcotics had not ended up being distributed, as well as the applicant's relatively minor role in the smuggling of foreigners, facts which did not directly affect the safety, health or personal integrity of another person, rather, they had to be considered aimed more generally at the stability of society and general security.
The court ruled that the FIS should have not refused to grant the applicant a residence permit on the basis of subsidiary protection, based on the exclusion clause of Section 88, Subsection 2, Clause 2 of the Aliens Act. The FIS decision was annulled partly concerning the application of the exclusion clause, and the case was sent back for re-examination.