Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

​​

26/06/2023
LV: The District Administrative Court of Riga concluded that a Ukrainian national must be excluded from subsidiary protection based on the State Security Service opinion corroborated with the findings of the court which examined the case ex officio
26/06/2023
LV: The District Administrative Court of Riga concluded that a Ukrainian national must be excluded from subsidiary protection based on the State Security Service opinion corroborated with the findings of the court which examined the case ex officio

ECLI
ECLI:LV:ADRJRIT:2023:0626.A420123223.7.S
Input Provided By
EUAA Information and Analysis Sector (IAS)
Type
Judgment
Original Documents
Relevant Legislative Provisions
Recast Qualification Directive (Directive 2011/95/EU on standards for the qualification of third-country nationals or stateless persons as BIP for a uniform status for refugees or for persons eligible for subsidiary protection)(recast QD)/or QD 2004/83/EC
Reference
Latvia, Administrative District Court [Administratīvā rajona tiesa], Applicant v Office of Citizenship and Migration Affairs of the Republic of Latvia, No. A42-01232-23/7, ECLI:LV:ADRJRIT:2023:0626.A420123223.7.S, 26 June 2023. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.
Permanent link to the case
https://caselaw.euaa.europa.eu/pages/viewcaselaw.aspx?CaseLawID=3534
Case history
Other information

European Union, Court of Justice of the European Union [CJEU], GM v Országos Idegenrendeszeti Főigazgatóság, Alkotmányvédelmi Hivatal, Terrorelhárítási Központ, C-159/21, ECLI:EU:C:2022:708, 22 September 2022. 

Abstract

The case concerned a Ukrainian national who applied for international protection in Latvia on 6 August 2022 and claimed that as a result of the war in Ukraine he would be in need of protection and that he was also seeking medical treatment. He worked as a driver in Dnipro district, then in Lviv from where he travelled to Crimea and to Latvia. The Office of Citizenship and Migration Affairs rejected his application by decision of 22 December 2022 and stated that the applicant applied for asylum frequently, within a short period of time, in several Member States without waiting for the outcome of the procedure, which indicates that the asylum applicant used the international protection procedure for other purposes than the need for protection. He used the asylum procedure for pursing his professional interests by using the possibility to stay in the EU. The Office considered the allegations of the applicant with regard to mobilisation not credible and the risk not real since the applicant stayed in Ukraine another half a year after the announcement of the general mobilisation, thus he is not in the interest of the Ukrainian authorities.


The applicant contested the decision before the District Administrative Court. The court found that there were no indications that the applicant would be at risk of persecution upon return because of his political opinions and opposition to the war.  It found the allegations related to the war in Ukraine and the risk of mobilisation to be contradictory. In addition, the applicant did not provide any medical documents confirming he had any illness for which he would be in need of treatment.  


The court also noted that neither the information of the country of origin nor the explanations provided by the applicant made it possible to conclude that the Ukrainian authorities would seek to force the applicant into military service, thereby forcing him to participate in war activities. The court analysed also whether the applicant would be eligible for subsidiary protection and noted that there is a full scale war with Russia. However, it examined the exclusion criteria and referred to the Judicial analysis – Exclusion: Articles 12 and 17 Qualification Directive (2011/95/EU), p. 12.  The court noted that the State Security Service has given an opinion that the applicant may pose a threat to State and public security. When assessing its validity, the court got acquainted with the opinion, and in order to ascertain the content of the conclusions included in the opinion, the court also became acquainted with the materials obtained through operational activities. In view of all the materials examined in the case, the court found that the opinion was not arbitrary and that the State Security Service has justified the reasons for having given an opinion that the applicant may pose a threat to national and public security.


The court has also referred to the CJEU judgement of 22 September 2022 in Case C-159/21,  GM v Országos Idegenrendeszeti Főigazgatóság, Alkotmányvédelmi Hivatal, Terrorelhárítási Központ, where it was found that an institution may not confine itself to implementing a decision taken by another institution, in order to take a decision not to grant international protection on that basis alone, or to withdraw it. On the contrary, the determining authority must have all relevant information and, in the light of that information, carry out its own assessment of the facts and circumstances in order to determine the substance of its decision and to justify it in its entirety. Thus, the Court has itself (ex officio) obtained additional evidence in the administrative case. The court noted that the applicant continuously disregarded the rules while he was accommodated in the reception center, as an example from 29 November 2022 to 21 April 2023, the applicant was placed 5 times in the premises of those violating the Internal Procedure, where a total of 41 days were spent. During those restrictions, the applicant attempted to flood the individual accommodation. He was placed there for non-compliance with the internal rules and the legal requirements of officials of the State Border Guard. In addition, during one of the remote oral hearings, he attempted to connect to the sitting completely naked, ignoring the instructions of an official of the State Border Guard. At the beginning of 2022, the applicant managed to connect to one of the centre's video surveillance equipment using a mobile phone owned by him and temporarily block its operation. Thus, the court stated that the information obtained from the State Border Guard and the State Police clearly indicates that the applicant's behaviour cannot be accepted in a democratic state, as he tends to violate norms of conduct and normative acts adopted in society. The characteristics of the applicant provided by the State Border Guard clearly indicate that his behaviour has been provocative, aggressive, and the applicant has clearly demonstrated disrespect not only with regard to officials of the State Border Guard, but also with representatives of the judiciary.


In light of the aforementioned, the court concluded that subsidiary protection status cannot be granted if there are reasons to believe that the person poses a threat to national security or public order and security. The court mentioned that the opinion of the State Security Service that the applicant may pose a threat to state and public security cannot be regarded as arbitrary. Consequently, the application for subsidiary protection was rejected.


Country of Decision
Latvia
Court Name
LV: Administrative District Court [Administratīvā rajona tiesa]
Case Number
No. A42-01232-23/7
Date of Decision
26/06/2023
Country of Origin
Ukraine
Keywords
Assessment of applications
Classified information
Danger to the national security or the community
EUAA Materials
EUAA Judicial Analysis / EUAA Professional Development Series
Exclusion
Subsidiary protection
Source
E-justice
Other Source/Information
E-justice