The applicant contested a Dublin transfer to Italy, alleging that he would be at risk of inhuman or degrading treatment. He also argued that he suffers from diabetes, and he is in continuous need of medication, and he would not have access to healthcare in due time. The Court of the Hague rejected the appeal and stated that although there are certain shortcomings in the asylum and reception system in Italy, the State Secretary may reply on the principle of mutual trust and interstate legitimate expectations. It stated also that it results from the AIDA country report that Dublin applicants have access to medical treatment, and they do not face a situation of material deprivation that would amount to a violation of Article 3 ECHR.