By decision of 28 September 2018, the French Office for the Protection of Refugees and Stateless Persons (OFPRA) rejected the asylum application of an Afghan national. On appeal, by decision of 15 June 2021, the National Court of Asylum granted the benefit of subsidiary protection. The OFPRA appealed the decision before the Council of State.
The Council noted that Article L-512-2 CESEDA provides that a person is excluded from international protection if there are serious reasons to believe that the person's activities on the territory are a grave threat to public order and public security. The Council further noted that in order to assess whether the activity of the asylum seeker on the territory constitutes a serious threat to public order and security justifying the exclusion from the benefit of international protection, the authorities must take into account all the actions attributable to the person, including any psychological instability, without the necessity of seeking to establish material and intentional elements specific to the commission of a crime.
Regarding the facts of the case, the Council noted that immediately after requesting international protection in France, in February 2018, the person made aggressive remarks against the staff of a communal center for social action and he threatened to set fire to the premises housing this establishment and made insulting statements against France. In July 2019, he was again violent and threatening towards the staff of a reception center for asylum applicants, declaring that he wanted to "cut their throats and drink their blood". In October 2019, following new disturbing remarks, he was hospitalised without consent and his release was ordered by the judge after one week, due to a procedural issue, while the competent psychiatrist proposed the maintenance of the measure. The CNDA decided that he did not have mental capacity before he started medical treatment but the Council considered that this does not diminish how dangerous the person is, so that mental instability is a factor to consider while assessing the seriousness of the threat to public order. The Council also noted that it emerged from the file that, even after receiving treatment, the person continued to make threatening remarks, specifically to burn everything if he did not obtain international protection and that his lawyer felt threatened.
The Council concluded that the CNDA had wrongly qualified the facts of the case, as despite the absence of a link established between the applicant and the jihadist movement and the fact that besides a suspended prison sentence for driving without insurance, he was not the subject of another sentence, he was still a threat to public order and security. The Council allowed the appeal and annulled the decision of the CNDA.