In this case the CGRS excluded the applicant from international protection mainly on the grounds of serious reasons to believe that he was guilty of crimes in the exercise of his duties in the Algerian army in the 1990s and, in particular, at the Centre Territorial de Recherche et d'Investigation (CTRI) in Blida, a place where, according to available information, torture and murder were systematic.
The Council for Alien Law Litigation (CALL) considered that all the elements constituting a war crime were present, namely:
(1) the existence of an armed conflict that is not by nature international;
(2) the commission of one of the crimes provided for in Article 8, 2, c, of the Rome Statute;
(3) the link between the crime and the armed conflict;
(4) knowledge of the link between the crime committed and the armed conflict.
CALL considered that, in this case, there are serious reasons to believe that the applicant conducted investigations and identified persons suspected of terrorism resulting in their murder or torture, and that this is a substantial and sufficient contribution to engaging his personal responsibility in the sense of Article 25 of the Rome Statute. CALL added that the fact that the acts of which the applicant was accused were part of the fight against terrorism do not justify murder and torture of people, whether proven terrorists or not.
Accordingly, CALL noted that the applicant did not present any grounds to exclude his personal responsibility in view of the serious reasons to believe that he participated in crimes against humanity and that he should be excluded from international protection on the basis of Article 1, section F, a, of the Geneva Convention.