Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

​​

05/11/2026

The ECtHR found that Bulgaria would violate Article 3 of the Convention if it were to remove an Uzbek applicant to his country of origin, without conducting a rigorous and ex nunc assessment into whether he would be exposed to a real risk of treatment contrary to Article 3 upon a return.

05/11/2026

The ECtHR found that Bulgaria would violate Article 3 of the Convention if it were to remove an Uzbek applicant to his country of origin, without conducting a rigorous and ex nunc assessment into whether he would be exposed to a real risk of treatment contrary to Article 3 upon a return.

ECLI
ECLI:CE:ECHR:2026:1105JUD002344125
Input Provided By
EUAA Information and Analysis Sector (IAS)
Other Source/Information
Type
Judgment
Original Documents
Relevant Legislative Provisions
European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR)
Reference
Council of Europe, European Court of Human Rights [ECtHR], A.M. v Bulgaria, no. 23441/25, ECLI:CE:ECHR:2026:1105JUD002344125, 05 November 2026. Link redirects to the English summary in the EUAA Case Law Database.
Permanent link to the case
https://caselaw.euaa.europa.eu/pages/viewcaselaw.aspx?CaseLawID=6362
Case history
Other information
Abstract

A.M., Uzbek national, applied for international protection in Bulgaria in October 2022. His application was rejected as manifestly unfounded by the State Agency for Refugees (SAR), which was subsequently confirmed on appeal. Three subsequent applications were rejected by SAR without an assessment on the merits. In February 2023, the immigration authorities issued a return order to Uzbekistan, upheld both on first and second appeal. Between July 2025 - June 2026, the applicant was imprisoned to serve a 18-month sentence for attempting to illegally cross the border to Romania in March and April 2025. He was placed in immigration detention after June 2026.


The applicant complained before the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) that his return to Uzbekistan would entail a violation of Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) because of a real risk of ill-treatment.


On admissibility, the court rejected the government's plea that the applicant would no longer be a victim within the meaning of Article 34 of the Convention, holding that his expressed wish to voluntarily return while he was in immigration detention and which was retracted before any return did not prove an unequivocal and informed waiver of his rights under Article 3 and was not capable of cancelling the return order. The court disagreed with the government that the applicant did not exhaust all national remedies, finding that the failure to pursue another appeal against the negative decision on his third subsequent application had no consequences in the overall context.


On the merits, the court reiterated that Member States have a procedural obligation under Article 3 to rigorously assess, before enforcing a return order, whether the person would be at risk of ill-treatment in the country of destination. This obligation is usually trigged when that person puts forward sufficiently substantiated arguments concerning such a risk. Applied in the present case, the court noted that the applicant reached that threshold as acknowledged by the Sofia city Administrative Court (SACS) which accepted that the applicant would be exposed to a real risk of ill-treatment upon a return to Uzbekistan.


The court held that the Bulgarian authorities failed to conduct a rigorous or a sufficiently adequate evaluation of the applicant's new evidence (an opinion by a psychologist, a forensic medical report and documents the applicant stated had been issued by the Uzbek authorities) in his subsequent applications. First, the court noted that the new evidence supporting his first and second subsequent applications was not subject to a genuine and fresh assessment. Particularly, SAR overlooked these documents even after SACS overturned the decision on the second subsequent application, following which both SAR and SACS contended to adopt the same approach of confining the assessment to the probative value of the new evidence. The court found that SAR and the courts disregarded the medical and psychological evidence presented by the applicant on grounds that they did not establish that the applicant was subjected to ill-treatment. Relatedly, SAR did not commission an expert opinion and limited the assessment to a finding that the applicant's scars were too small, and his documented injuries were not sufficiently serious and consistent with his account. The court further found that SAR discounted the documents allegedly originating from Uzbekistan based on assumption of formal non-compliance with official Uzbek documents, without conducting a concrete and evidence-based assessment of their authenticity, supplemented, where necessary, by expert assistance. Irrespective of whether the authorities had to deal with three subsequent applications submitted over a short period of time between each other, however the court reminded that the absolute nature of Article 3 of the Convention could not absolve Member States of their duties under this article.


The court emphasised that the assessments conducted by SAR and the courts remained largely retrospective by focusing merely on whether the applicant's allegation of previous torture suffered in February 2022 was established, omitting to assess that allegations prospectively and by taking into account other events, such as for example: the alleged criminal charges arising from his supposed participation in the war in Ukraine, the purported warnings that he would be arrested, and the documented incidence of ill-treatment of persons taken into custody in Uzbekistan. The court also noted that no authority looked into general information about ill-treatment by the police and in prisons in Uzbekistan, nor reasoned sufficiently on why that information did not support the applicant's assertions and evidence relating to his individual circumstances.


The court further noted that the government remained silent on the question of whether the migration authorities would examine the alleged risk of ill-treatment faced by the applicant in Uzbekistan with the requisite rigour before enforcing the return order. In this regard, it noted that there was no relevant case-law of the administrative courts or any publicly available practice of the migration authorities to clarify on the application of Article 44a(5) of the Law on Foreigners in Bulgaria at the moment of enforcing a return order.


Against this background, the court concluded that it could not rule out a scenario according to which the Bulgarian authorities would reach the same conclusion after conducting a rigorous examination of the applicant's case, namely that his removal to Uzbekistan would not expose him to a real risk of treatment contrary to Article 3 of the Convention. However, it ruled that his removal to Uzbekistan without the authorities having conducted such a rigorous and ex nunc examination would amount to a breach of Article 3 of the Convention.


Although it found that a violation of Article 3 ECHR did not occur in the case, the court held that its finding constituted 'sufficient just satisfaction for any mental suffering endured by the applicant on account of the fear that he might be subjected to ill-treatment in Uzbekistan if returned there'.


The court issued interim measures on 1 August 2025 ordering the government under Rule 39 not to remove the applicant to Uzbekistan until further notice and decided not to lift that measure by decision of 23 September 2025.


 


 


Country of Decision
Council of Europe
Court Name
CoE: European Court of Human Rights [ECtHR]
Case Number
no. 23441/25
Date of Decision
05/11/2026
Country of Origin
Uzbekistan
Keywords
Assessment of applications
Assessment of evidence/assessment of documents
Return/Removal/Deportation
Special procedures
Subsequent application
Torture or inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment
RETURN